In this discussion, Patrick Radden Keefe, author of 'Empire of Pain' and creator of 'Say Nothing', delves into the urgent protests by farmers in Westminster against government budget changes, particularly regarding inheritance tax. He explores the emotional and financial toll on family farms and the historical echoes of such unrest. They also touch on the complex narratives of the Troubles in Northern Ireland, highlighting the struggles for truth amid trauma, and the connections between the past and present societal grievances.
Farmers are rallying at Westminster due to proposed inheritance tax reforms threatening the sustainability of family farms and agricultural heritage.
The protests highlight broader rural discontent with government policies, signaling potential political implications for parties like the Labour party and right-wing movements.
Deep dives
Farmers Protest Inheritance Tax Reforms
Farmers are rallying against proposed changes to inheritance tax reforms announced in the budget, drawing significant attention and anger at Whitehall. The reforms affect Agricultural Property Relief (APR) and Business Property Relief (BPR), which have historically exempted farms from inheritance tax, arguing that otherwise, family farms may be broken up due to financial strain. Amidst the protest, farmers expressed fears that new limits on these tax exemptions would force them to sell their land, particularly affecting those whose land values have increased significantly over the years. Many attendees voiced solidarity with fellow farmers, asserting that despite potentially not being impacted themselves, the reforms symbolize a larger threat to agricultural heritage and sustainability.
The Impact of Rising Land Prices
The rising value of farmland in the UK has exacerbated concerns about inheritance tax, as land prices have surged considerably due to investments from wealthy buyers. Farmers argue that while the government estimates only a small number of estates will be affected by tax changes, they believe the actual number is much higher due to the significant assets associated with farming operations being underestimated. The disparity lies in the cap situation where agricultural assets may still be exempt from taxes, but as the cost of land rises, more farmers risk crossing the threshold, endangering their ability to pass their farms on to the next generation. Farmers fear they will face dire financial burdens that could compromise their operational viability and traditional practices.
Cultural and Emotional Connections to Farming
The emotional and cultural significance of family farms in Britain plays a major role in the fervor surrounding the inheritance tax debate. Farmers highlight the ancestral ties to their land and the commitment to generational farming, which is framed as integral to British identity and sovereignty in agriculture. Influential figures, like Jeremy Clarkson, amplify this sentiment through contemporary discussions, bridging the gap between public consciousness and the realities of farming life. Such emotional stakes position the farming community as a potential symbol of broader rural grievances against government policies, even yielding political implications as discontent against the Labour party surfaces.
Wider Political Implications for the Farming Community
The tensions surrounding farming and inheritance tax reflect broader discontent within rural areas and the political landscape in Britain. Farmers express frustrations not only about tax legislation but also growing governmental red tape and policies perceived as detrimental to traditional farming practices. This sentiment, coupled with longstanding conservative skepticism towards the Labour party in rural settings, creates fertile ground for political movements aimed at representing farmer interests, which could potentially benefit right-wing parties, including figures like Nigel Farage. The protests serve as a rallying point that may resonate with the public, reflecting a deeper critique of government disconnect from rural challenges, and potentially uniting various forms of unrest within the country.
Later in this episode we talk to Patrick Radden Keefe, author of global bestseller 'Empire of Pain'. His new Disney+ drama 'Say Nothing' tells the story of murder and memory during The Troubles in 1970's Northern Ireland, and solves one of that time's most egregious crimes.
But we start on the streets of Whitehall with the farmers storming Westminster, and their rallying cry - "Starmer Farmer Harmer". How has the new government got on their wrong side so quickly? How damaging will the policies in the budget REALLY be for farmers? And will the Chancellor back down?
Editor: Tom Hughes
Executive Producer: Louis Degenhardt
Producer: Natalie Indge
Digital Editor: Michaela Walters
Social Media Editor: Georgia Foxwell
Video Production: Rory Symon, Shane Fennelly & Arvind Badewal