E205 - Mobility in America’s Past, Present, and Future w/ Yoni Appelbaum
Apr 1, 2025
auto_awesome
Yoni Appelbaum, Deputy Executive Editor at The Atlantic and author of "Stuck," dives into the complexities of housing and mobility in America. He discusses how privilege and property ownership have shaped opportunities, often at the cost of community. Yoni highlights the troubling history of zoning laws rooted in discrimination and critiques the cultural obsession with single-family homes. He also explores how policies intended to uplift often perpetuate inequality, revealing the intricate ties between social mobility and housing dynamics in the U.S.
American geographic mobility has historically driven societal change, yet it often sacrifices community cohesion in pursuit of opportunity.
Zoning laws and discriminatory practices have perpetuated socioeconomic inequalities, limiting access to mobility for marginalized groups in America.
The preference for single-family homes post-World War II strengthened social isolation, making it difficult for low-income populations to access better opportunities.
Deep dives
The Historical Context of Geographic Mobility
Geographic mobility has historically been a defining feature of American society, with individuals frequently relocating to seize new opportunities. The early colonists established a culture of serial mobility, as they moved to create communities that promised better prospects. This movement was not merely physical but also embedded in the legal and social fabric of America, allowing individuals to choose their residency without communal constraints. Over the centuries, this culture of movement has shaped the nation's identity and economy, with frequent relocations facilitating social and economic advancement.
The Impact of Capitalism on Mobility
Capitalism has played a crucial role in shaping American geographic mobility, yet it is not the sole factor influencing socioeconomic opportunities. The discussion reveals that while unrestrained capitalism has created deep societal inequalities, structural factors such as zoning laws and discriminatory practices have had significant impacts. These forces have created barriers to entry for marginalized groups, restricting their mobility and ability to pursue economic advancement. A historical examination of these elements underscores the complexity of how capitalism interacts with regulatory frameworks to influence mobility.
Mobility and Racial Discrimination
The patterns of mobility in America have often excluded racial and ethnic minorities, who have faced systemic barriers to movement. Discrimination has historically restricted groups designated as outsiders from accessing the same opportunities as their white counterparts. This has created a paradox where the right to mobility is affirmed for some while denied to others, particularly African Americans who have consistently asserted this right in the face of oppression. The historical narrative illustrates the struggle for equality and the ongoing fight against the forces that seek to limit mobility based on race.
The Transformation of Housing and Urban Development
In the 20th century, housing policies significantly altered the landscape of mobility, with zoning codes and mortgage regulations shaping modern America. The establishment of zoning laws, initially designed to segregate communities, has contributed to a more stratified society, where movement toward opportunity is increasingly restricted. As suburbanization took hold post-World War II, a preference for single-family homes emerged, reinforcing social isolation and diminishing community ties. This shift has perpetuated a culture where the affluent benefit from mobility while low-income populations are confined to less desirable areas, exacerbating economic disparities.
Current Challenges and Future Prospects
Today, mobility in America faces significant challenges due to regulatory barriers and a growing distrust of government intervention. The cumulative effects of restrictive zoning laws have resulted in a crisis where the most economically disadvantaged populations are pushed away from regions of opportunity. There's a pressing need for comprehensive reforms that enable equitable access to housing and economic opportunity for all Americans. The historical context provided reveals that the decline in mobility is a recent phenomenon, suggesting that intentional policy changes could restore the fundamental American ideal of opportunity through movement.
Yoni Appelbaum, a deputy executive editor at The Atlantic, joins the program to talk about his book Stuck: How the Privileged and the Propertied Broke the Engine of American Opportunity. They discuss mobility in the US and how that might sacrifice community for opportunity, the “frontier” as a way of taking land and easing class antagonism, the birth of American zoning from anti-Chinese practices in 19th century California, the move toward the single-family home and it being a symbol of the American identity, how we can make homes accessible once more for working Americans, and more.
For an ad-free experience and much more content, subscribe!
