#61 Could Jesus have been female? What about polygamy?
Apr 15, 2021
auto_awesome
Tom tackles whether Jesus could have been incarnated as a woman, explaining polygamy in scripture, and biblical commands on men and women speaking in church. The discussion explores the significance of Jesus' male identity, the interpretation of 1 Corinthians 14:34, and the contrasting views on polygamy in the Bible. Jesus affirms the original intention for marriage to be between one man and one woman.
The question of whether Jesus could have been a woman delves into broader theological considerations of God's freedom and the givenness of the Christian revelation, emphasizing the deeper meaning and completeness of the biblical narrative.
Polygamy in the Bible presents a complex dynamic that evolves throughout the biblical narrative, with the teachings of Jesus in the New Testament emphasizing the original creational intention of marriage as the union of one man and one woman, guiding the interpretation of polygamy in the Old Testament.
Deep dives
Could Jesus have been a woman?
The question of whether Jesus could have been a woman is an interesting one. While some argue that Jesus being a Jewish man was significant for his mission, the question of could it have been otherwise leads to broader theological considerations of God's freedom and the givenness of the Christian revelation. The biblical story emphasizes God's deliberate creation of humans with complementary roles, with Jesus seen as the fulfillment of God's purpose. The roles of male and female are not identical, and Jesus becoming human as a male is viewed in light of the concept of the church as the bride of Christ. Therefore, the question of Jesus being a woman or non-Jewish is seen as operating at a superficial level when compared to the deeper meaning and completeness of the biblical narrative.
Examining the role of women in the church
The question of women's roles within the church is a complex and debated topic. In 1 Corinthians 14:34, Paul mentions that women should be silent in the assemblies and in submission. However, there are alternative interpretations of this passage. It is important to note that Paul also acknowledges women praying and prophesying in other parts of the New Testament and describes women as apostles and deacons. The context and cultural practices of the time also play a role in understanding these instructions. Some scholars suggest that the issue of women speaking in assemblies might have been related to language barriers or disruptions caused by cultural practices during worship. The reference to submission may connect to the wider ordering of creation. Overall, the topic of women's roles in the church involves nuanced interpretations and requires careful examination of the broader biblical narrative.
The complexity of polygamy in the Bible
Polygamy in the Bible presents a complex dynamic that evolves throughout the biblical narrative. The presence of polygamy in the lives of figures like Abraham, Jacob, David, and Solomon raises questions about its moral status. While polygamy was accepted in certain contexts and not explicitly criticized, the stories often reveal the difficulties and consequences associated with such relationships. For instance, the tensions and rivalries between wives and the negative outcomes for individuals and the wider community. When approaching this issue, it is crucial to consider the progression of understanding within the biblical story. Jesus' teachings in the New Testament emphasize the original creational intention of marriage as the union of one man and one woman. Thus, the New Testament understanding guides the interpretation of polygamy in the Old Testament, highlighting the importance of discerning the overall trajectory of biblical revelation.
Tom tackles questions on whether Jesus could have been incarnated as a woman instead of a man, how you explain polygamy in scripture, and the question of Biblical commands about men and women speaking in church.