Former New York Times editor James Bennet spills the tea on the infamous Tom Cotton column that got him fired. Controversy and fallout surrounding Bennet and Donald McNeil Jr. discussed. The influence of social media on media organizations and power dynamics explored.
Journalists' shift from pursuing truth to pursuing social justice directly has impacted media organizations.
The rise of social media and rejection of objectivity has led to a disregard for traditional journalistic norms and an imbalance of power within media organizations.
Deep dives
The Shift in Journalistic Thinking
Bennett discusses the transformation in the philosophy of journalists over the past decade. He points out that journalists used to see their role as pursuing truth, equipping readers with information to form their own judgments. However, today journalists prioritize pursuing social justice directly, believing that objectivity ignores the marginalized and benefits those in power.
Fear and Power Dynamics in Media Organizations
Bennett highlights the impact of social media and Twitter on media organizations, creating an atmosphere of fear among colleagues and bosses. He notes that after the Trump election, many journalists felt a responsibility to lead the resistance. This shift, combined with a fear of employees and an upending of hierarchical power dynamics, has affected the functioning of media organizations.
An Upheaval of Journalistic Norms
Bennett explains that the rise of social media and the rejection of objectivity has led to a disregard for traditional journalistic norms. Managers now fear the younger journalists, contributing to a lack of authority and an imbalance of power. This upending of norms has resulted in an environment where even the least contributing individuals are feared by management.
This week on the Primo edition of Blocked and Reported, Jesse and Katie discuss a recent article by former New York Times editor James Bennet on the infamous 2020 Tom Cotton column that got Bennet fired. Plus, toilets.