Open Source Carbon Footprints

Chris Adams is joined by Thibaud Colas; product lead at Torchbox, president of the Django Software Foundation, and lead on Wagtail CMS. They explore the role of open source projects in tackling digital carbon emissions and discuss Wagtail's pioneering carbon footprint reporting, sustainable default settings, and grid-aware website features, all enabled through initiatives like Google Summer of Code. Thibaud shares how transparency, contributor motivation, and clear governance can drive impactful sustainability efforts in web development, and why measuring and reducing emissions in the Python ecosystem matters now more than ever.

TRANSCRIPT BELOW:

Thibaud Colas: If you get your contributors to work on high value and high impact things, that's the best way to motivate them. So that's kind of the idea here is, formalize that we have a goal to reduce our footprint. And by virtue of this, we, you know, make it a more impactful thing for people to work on by having those numbers, by communicating this specific change to images, here is the potential for it to reduce emissions.

Chris Adams: Hello, and welcome to Environment Variables, brought to you by the Green Software Foundation. In each episode, we discuss the latest news and events surrounding green software. On our show, you can expect candid conversations with top experts in their field who have a passion for how to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions of software.

I'm your host, Chris Adams. 

 Hello and welcome to Environment Variables, where we bring you the latest news and updates from the world of sustainable software development. I'm your host, Chris Adams. If you want the way we build software to be more sustainable and more inclusive, one way to improve the chances of this happening is to make it easier to build it that way,

so building greener software goes with the grain of the software framework you're using. And one way to do that is update the defaults that prioritize accessibility and sustainability in the framework itself. One of the people I've seen who really exemplifies this idea and this approach is my guest today, Thibaud Colas,

a lead developer at the software agency, Torchbox, the current president of the Django Software Foundation and the product lead at the popular Wagtail Content Management System, which is also built on top of Django. The Wagtail CMS powers sites like the NASA Jet Propulsion Labs website, the University of Pennsylvania's website, the Tate Gallery, and even the main NHS website in the UK.

So while it might not have the same coverage as WordPress, which covers more than a third of the internet, still powers a large number of, a number of large sites, and changes made in this framework can have a decent reach. So changes made here are worth discussing because the Wagtail CMS docs, in my view, are probably the most advanced talking about sustainability for any open source CMS right now.

And there's a clear link between sustainability and embodied admissions of the hardware that you actually, that people need to use to access your websites too. And with that in mind, you can see it's got some of the most developed accessibility features as well. But we're getting ahead of ourselves though, and Thibaud is in a much better place to talk about this than me.

So Thibaud, thank you so much for joining us. Can I give you the floor to introduce yourself for our listeners?

Thibaud Colas: Hi. It's my pleasure, Chris. Thank you for having me. I'm Thibaud, my pronouns are he/him. And, yeah, I'm the product lead, for the Wagtail CMS at Torchbox. Wagtail is an open source project and products, and Torchbox, we are the original creators of the project and main contributors. And, yeah, as product lead I helped shape the work of Torchbox on Wagtail and of other contributors as well. And, as president of the Jingo Software Foundation, I have similar responsibilities for the Django Project. Django being a big Web framework, one of the biggest on Python. Just to give you a sense of scale, Wagtail, that's on the order of 10 to 20,000 sites out there. And Django, we're talking half a million to a million projects.

Chris Adams: Cool. Thank you, Thibaud. And, Thibaud, where are you calling me from today? Because, I,

Thibaud Colas: I'm in Cambridge, UK. got started on Wagtail way back in New Zealand,

but travels took me back to Europe and UK. I'm from France originally.

Chris Adams: Oh, cool. Alright, thank you for that. So I'm Chris Adams. I am the co-chair of the Green Software Foundation Policy Working Group. I'm also one of the, we're also, we also have show notes for this.

So all the projects and links that we discuss will be available. So in your quest to basically develop better sustain sustainable software engineering skills, that will all be available for this. So we look up podcast.greensoftware.foundation to find that. Alright, Thibaud, we've got a bunch of questions to get through.

Shall we start?

Thibaud Colas: Yeah, sure.

Chris Adams: Okay. Alright. So one thing that I, that really came up on my radar a few years ago when I saw this, was that Wagtail was one of the few, one of the only projects I've seen so far that actually tried to put together a kind of carbon footprint inventory of all over the websites that it's responsible for.

And I remember the posts and we'll share a link to this explaining some of this and some figures for this. Like "we reckon that Wagtail was kind of responsible for around like more than 8,000 tons of CO2 per year from all the sites that we run." Could you maybe talk a little bit about, basically the approach you took for that and why you even did that.

'Cause there's probably a few discussions about decisions you had to make and trade offs you had to choose between model uses and coming up with numbers and all that. But maybe we go from the beginning about why you started that. Then we can dive into some of the details.

Thibaud Colas: Yeah. Yeah. Well, simply enough, you know, when you start to think about the impact of technology on what we build, as developers, at least we love to try and quantify that impact. You know, put some figures on there. And the carbon footprint of websites, well, when you think of the sites, there are lots of components.

There's things that happen in the browser, things that happen server side. And when I say server side these days, you know, the infrastructure is quite varied and somewhat opaque as well. So yeah, server side. So when it comes to Wagtail, with it being an open source project, people are, it's quite interoperable with all sorts of databases and file storage and web browsers obviously. So it becomes quite tricky to

actually put a number on the emissions of one site. And I guess that's where we started at Torchbox specifically trying to quantify the emissions of our clients for 50 to a hundred websites. And from there, you know, you realize that, it makes lots of sense to try and do it for the whole white tail ecosystem so that you can make hopefully decisions for the whole ecosystem based on sites out there. So yeah.

I think it was back in 2023 that we did this first, and there were definitely lots of ways back then to quantify sites' emissions. We didn't necessarily reinvent any, but we tried and understand, okay, when we have little knowledge of those thousands of websites out there, which methodologies should we be referring to when we try and put those figures together? So I say specifically methodologies because I think that's one of the potential pitfalls for developers starting in there. They assume that, somewhat like performance, you can

have quite finite reproducible numbers, but we're just not there yet with the carbon footprint of websites.

So I think it's really important that you combine. So in our case, you combine web sustainability guidelines, related methodologies, so it's called sustainable web design model, and that you also combine things that look more closely at the servers, you know, CPU and resource use,

and also other aspects in the browser.

Chris Adams: Okay, cool. And one thing that I actually quite appreciated when you did this or when, the, you know, the team you are part of did this, was that you, yeah you shared all these numbers, but you also shared the underlying spreadsheets and the working so that other folks who might be running projects themselves can use as either a starting point or even possibly challenge and propose maybe improvements as we learn more about this because we know that

it's a difficult field to kind of navigate right now, but it is getting a bit easier, and as we learn more things, we are able to kind of incorporate that into the way we kind of model and think about some of the interventions we might make to maybe reduce the environmental footprint or improve it basically?

Thibaud Colas: Yeah. Yeah, it's a, you might actually be aware of a project, Chris, the HTTP Archive's Web Almanac. They reviewed the whole of the Web on the other of 20 million websites every year, and they produced numbers based on this data set of websites. So that's kind of, I suppose what I tried to follow with this methodology as well, of sharing our results to the fullest extent so that other people can verify the numbers and potentially also put same numbers together

for their own sites, individual sites, or also site ecosystem. So, you know, Wagtail, it's a CMS among many other CMSs. There's lots of competitors in that

space and nothing would make me happier than seeing other CMSs do the same and hopefully reuse

what we've spent time putting together. And yeah, obviously when we do this once for, Wagtail, we can try and do it also for Django.

So there's also these benefits of, across the whole tech stack, having that kind of methodology more nailed down for people who make those decisions. You know, like product level decisions.

Chris Adams: Oh, okay, cool. And just like we have release cycles for presumably new websites or like new CMSs and everything like that, as we learn more, we might be able to improve the precision and the accuracy of some of this to refine the assumptions, right. And, you know, many eyes make bugs shallow. So Drupal folks, if you're hearing this, or WordPress folks, yeah.

Over to you basically.

Thibaud Colas: Exactly. And you know, definitely the methodologies evolve over time. So one of the recent ones I really like is how, with Firefox browser, you can measure the CPU usage to render a single page.

And just that is becoming so much more accessible these days that we could potentially do it on every release of the CMS.

Chris Adams: Cool. Well, let's come back to that because this is one thing that I found quite interesting about the, some of the work that you folks have been doing is not only were you starting to measure this, but you're looking at actually options you can take to maybe set new defaults or improve some of this stuff.

And, as I understand it, Wagtail, you've had some luck actually finding some funding and finding ways to basically cover the cost of people to essentially work on this stuff via things like the Google Summer of Code and things like that. Maybe you could talk a little bit about some of that, because as I understand it, you're in year three of successfully saying, "Hey, this is important.

Can someone fund it?" And then actually getting some funding to pay people to work on this stuff.

Thibaud Colas: Yeah. Yeah. Well, yeah. So, once you have those numbers in place as to, you know, how much emissions the sites out there produce, try and refine it down to a few specific aspects of the sites that, you know, you go through

the quick wins, you figure out what you have the most leverage over, and then you realize there's this and that concepts that are potentially quite fundable if you

know just how to frame it and who to talk to. And we, as Torchbox, we have quite a few clients that care about the footprint of their websites,

but it's definitely also a good avenue. The Google Summer of Code program you mentioned, it's about getting new people excited with open source as new contributors in the open source space.

It's entirely funded by Google. And essentially Google, they trust projects like Wagtail and Django to come up with those ideas that are, you know, impactful, and also sensible avenues for people to get up to speed with open source. And so, yeah, we, it's been three years now that we've done this with a sustainability focus where we try every year to have an idea in this space.

And I think it's quite interesting as an option because, few people that come to open source, you know, early in their

career are aware of sustainability. It's quite a good, opportunity for them to learn something very new, even if they might already know the technology like Django and Wagtail. And for us, it allows us to work on those concepts that, you know, we saw the data, we saw the promise. So I think, the first year we did 2023, we looked at image optimization.

It's actually quite a big thing for a CMS, in my opinion at least, that, you know, people wanna add lovely visuals to all of their pages and you know, maybe sometimes there is a case for fewer images if you want to lower the footprints. But it's definitely also a case where you have to have images, you want them to be

as low footprint as possible. So for that specific project, we were joined by two contributors, who helped us. One worked on the AVIF support in the CMS. AVIF being one of the newer image formats that promises to have a lower file size

than the alternative. And the other one helped us essentially make, the APIs we have in Wagtail to generate multiple images, make that more ergonomic. So you'd be able to generate, say, three different variations of an image and then only send to the user the one that fits the best for how the image is displayed

so that hopefully it's smaller.

So it's this responsive images concept.

Chris Adams: Oh, I see. So you're basically are. It may be that the server needs to generate some of these images 'cause you don't have control over who's accessing your website. But when someone's accessing something with maybe a small, like a touch device or something, rather than send this massive thing over the wire, you can send something which is appropriately smaller.

So it might take up less space inside the memory and the DOM and less over the wire as well, right.

Thibaud Colas: Exactly. You were talking about the grain of Wagtail. Wagtail has very few opinions as far as how you create the pages, but we definitely try and leverage the grain of HTML, so this responsive images pattern is quite well put together in HTML and Web standards and, yeah, really happy with the results.

Honestly, I think for the specific trial sites we rolled it out, it was on the other of 30% lower page weight and, for the Wagtail web at large, like every year we see the improvements in those, audits about how much usage there is of modern image format, how much usage there is of responsive images.

We see the figures improve. So, really cool.

Chris Adams: Cool. We should actually share links to some of these things as well, actually. 'Cause one of the wonderful things about working with an open source project is you can say, well, if you want this to be a norm, then is the PR you could copy basically, right.

Thibaud Colas: Yeah. And something like AVIF support, I'm sure we'll talk about it at some points. Definitely. You know, we couldn't create the AVIF decoders and so on ourselves, so we've been relying on the Python ecosystem at large. And yeah. Now those things are in a place where lots of projects have those decoders where available.

Chris Adams: Cool. Are there any things, are there any other like, so that's, that was year one and this is year three and I think I can probably share with you is that, so we're a nonprofit organization. We publish a library called CO2.js. We've added, we've managed to get some funding from Google once for the Google Summer of Docs, not Google Summer of Code, where they actually funded us to make some of this library a bit easier for other people to use. And we found that quite helpful because that's been one of the ways people come to this for the first time is they use a library called CO2.js. And that wasn't something we could prioritize. So it's, kind of nice.

It just, it would be nice if there's more organizations funding this kind of work rather than just like one Web giant. Like it's nice that Google is doing this, but if you too work in a large tech company and you wanna actually fund this stuff or make it easier for your engineers to do this, then,

yeah, it's right there, folks. Okay. So maybe I can ask about some of the other years that you have running, like is there anything else that you'd like, like to talk about or draw people's attention to for 

some of the other ones?

Thibaud Colas: Google Summer of Code is a three month program, but lots of those things, to be honest, they keep chugging along in the background

for quite a while and making improvements. So, year two of this, we worked on the starter project for Wagtail. So a starter website where, just like as you mentioned earlier, the defaults, trying to make sure that it's easier for people to get a site up and running that has all of the right things in place to be low impact.

So that time, a contributor, Aman Pandey, helped us with the designs

as well as the coding of these templates. And, just from the get go, the idea was let's measure the designs even before they touch a Web browser. Let's make sure that we understand all of the, you know, newer standards, like the Web specific guidelines that those designs have that baked in so that when you generate the

sites, you are guaranteed better results. so this template, this project template's still in progress, but the designs at least are super promising. And year three, so year three,

starting as of this week, just to be clear, is grid awareness. 

So grid awareness is a big term. Essentially it means looking at ways that, as the website loads in, your browser, it'll be optimized based on the carbon intensity of your computer and your local grid electricity. So what that means is if it would take, produce lots of emissions for the site to load in your browser, we try and make the website optimized for the emissions to lower. And yeah, so our contributor for this, Rohit, he's been around the Wagtail community for a bit and has this interest in sustainability.

And again, I think a great example of something that will tangibly help us reduce the impact of Wagtail websites out there and also make more developers aware of those patterns and, you know, the underlying need for those patterns.

Chris Adams: I am glad you mentioned the names actually. 'cause, on the initial year, I was working closely, I was working with Aman Pandey and I think one of your colleagues might be working with Paarth. So, hi Paarth. Hi Aman. I hope you're listening. It's really nice to actually see this. 'Cause these were people who are, like you said, early career didn't get that much exposure, but honestly compared to like the industry, they're relative experts now. And that might say more about the state of the industry is right now, but is, this was something I actually found it quite nice working with someone who was relatively young, who was actually really keen and honestly worryingly productive, did make me worry a bit about my own job going forward.

But yeah, this was one thing that was, really cool from that actually.

Thibaud Colas: Paarth and Aman are two of the mentors working with me on this Wagtail websites

project this year. So this is also the other goal of this Google Summer of Code program is retaining those people in the open source world and, yeah, definitely, you know, we are at a point now where we have more and more of those people coming to open source with that realization. There's way more room for this to happen on other projects like Wagtail, but, baby steps. 

Chris Adams: Oh wow. I didn't realize that you actually had, there was a kind of program to kind of build like, I guess like invest in, provide some of that leadership so people who prioritize this are able to kind of have a bit more of influence inside that project, for example.

Thibaud Colas: Yeah, exactly. Well, you know, open source, we have, we have very different incentives compared to the corporates and, yeah, for profit world. So we don't necessarily have, super clear ways to retain people, but definitely people who are interested and have the drive, like we try and retain them by having them move from contributors first time to repeat maintainers, mentors and so on.

Chris Adams: Oh, cool. All right, so that is a nice segue to allow us to talk a little bit about, I guess, taking ownership of carbon emissions and like the strategies that you have there. Because, one thing we should add into this list is that there's actually a roadmap for Wagtail specifically.

I think it's, is RFC 90 or is there a particular term for like a request for comments or something that you folks use to kind of talk about governance and talk about what you prioritize in this? 

Thibaud Colas: It's a bit of a running joke. In Python they have the PEP

proposals, Python Enhancement Proposal, and in Django they have the DEPs. People have been wondering if Wagtail should have the WEPs,

but right now we just have RFC, requests for comments.

And Yeah. ,It's just a super, like, simple way for us to invite.

It's really rather than, you know, create those governance, or technical architecture decision. Go documents, in, private chats, put them in public, and then invite feedback from others. So, you know, we've had this RFC for, couple years now, I believe. I got some good support from one of the experts out there on open source governance, Lauri Apple.

She coached me through, you know, trying to build up community momentum and also trying to find ways to make this reusable again beyond Wagtail and yeah, so this RFC, like, if you're deep in this space, it's nothing super special. 

It's about building awareness, finding opportunities for fundraising,

working on the right concepts, but I think it's quite unique for open source projects to have that kind of clear, like direction for those things. Open source projects don't even necessarily have a roadmap of any kind to start with. And one on specific topics like this I think it's really important. I think there's something Lauri says often, which is

if you get your contributors to work on high value and high impact things, that's the best way to motivate them. So that's kind of the idea here is formalize that we have a goal to reduce our footprint. And by virtue of this, we, you know, make it a more impactful thing for people to work on

by having those numbers, by communicating this specific change to images, here is the potential for it to reduce emissions.

Chris Adams: Oh, I see. Okay. So I've just followed the link to the RFC that you have here, and there's actually quite a lot of stuff here. So I can see a link to the free green software for practitioners course for people who don't know that much about it, I can see that Wagtail itself has a sustainability statement.

So like this, these are our priorities. So there's some immediate kind of explicit statement that this is something you care about. And then as I understand it, there's some references to other things. So there's the prior work, with the GSOC, Google Summer of Code. There's references to the W3C Web sustainability guidelines and a bunch of stuff like that.

And there's few other. We'll show a link to this because I think it's actually a really good example for other people to be aware of or see, like, this is what a relatively large mature project does, and this is what it looks like when they start prioritizing this. Because, yeah, there are some, there are some organizations that are doing this quite well.

I know that there is a .NET based CMS that I've totally forgotten the name, Umbraco CMS, also have some quite strong, have also quite advanced in this. And they're another good example of this, but there's kind of, when you talk about, okay, prioritizing this and responsibility, there's a whole question about, okay, well,

whose job is it or who's responsible for this? Because you are building a piece of software and like you might not get that much control over who adopts the software, for example, like I think when you shared this breakdown, we saw like a, I think you mentioned there was one Vietnamese website, Vinmec, that was like making up like a third of the reported emissions. 

Thibaud Colas: Put me in touch.

Chris Adams: Yeah.

Thibaud Colas: Yes. So this is a very, with the caveat that carbon accounting

isn't my expertise, you know, in the corporate world, we have the very clear, greenhouse gas GHG protocol, and scope one, scope two, scope three standards. And in that corporate world, I think, there's this, I think scope three, category 11, use of 

Chris Adams: use of products. 

Thibaud Colas: The use of, it's worse than that. It's use of sold products.

Chris Adams: That's it. Yeah. Sold. Yeah.

Thibaud Colas: So if you're not a corporation, we're not a corporation, wagtail, we, have about 20 contributors on the

core team. And if you don't sell your product, which standards are you meant to be using, then, to decide essentially which, which emissions we should be reporting on?

So the disfigure of the carbon footprint of Watta on the order of five to 10 thousand tons a year. That's assuming, you know, we take some ownership for this usage of Wagtail and of the websites built with it. And it's actually, I think, quite tricky to navigate in the open source world.

Understanding, which standards of reporting are, helpful because, you know, in some respects, people who shop for a website builder or CMS or any tech really kind of expect specific standards to be met. You know, you mentioned having a sustainability statement. No one's expecting that just yet in the open source world, but we definitely want things to move that way. And we have to, you know, make sure that when we create those figures they are somewhat comparable to other projects. So, yeah, I guess for Wagtail, you know, there's the fact that you don't control who uses

it and you don't control how they use it, either. So, if someone wants to, you know, make a site that's partly big

and it's partly popular in some country, maybe

Chris Adams: Yeah. 

Thibaud Colas: adult entertainment websites

that don't have any. 

Chris Adams: Does PornHub go on WordPress' ledger? Right? is it on their accounts? Yeah.

Thibaud Colas: Exactly. We have a few like this in the Wagtail and Django world and, you know, technology, you know, it's open source license. We have no interest in taking any kind of control or having a more contractual relationship with those projects, but we still need to navigate how to account for their use essentially. 

What actually got me started on this, Chris,

I think it's worth I mentioned, is the work of Mozilla

and Mozilla Foundation. They were the first ones I saw, I think back in 2020 reporting the use of Firefox browser

as part of the emissions of Mozilla. And it was, I think it was 98% of the emissions of Firefox were like, sorry, the emissions of Mozilla came from Firefox.

And it just got me thinking, you know, for Wagtail and Django, obviously it's a similar type of scale.

Chris Adams: Also with Firefox, the browser, like you don't necessarily pay Firefox to use it, but you may be paying via the fact that your atten, you know, you kind of pay in your attention. And the fact that when you click on a search, an ad in Google, one of the search services, Firefox is being paid that way.

So you're not actually making a direct monetary, like you're not giving them money directly, but there is payment taking place and changing hands. And this is one thing that is actually quite difficult to figure out. Like, okay, how do you represent that stuff? Because like you said, it's not sold per se, or you're not paying in money, but you may be be paying in something else, for example.

And, it's almost like you know this, I mean it's, I guess it's a good thing that you do see some of these protocols for reporting being updated because they're not necessarily a good fit for how lots of like new business models on the internet actually work, for example.

Thibaud Colas: Yeah. And it's really important for us to get in this space as, open source technologists, I believe. Because I mentioned procurement. Definitely the expectations are rising in Europe, in particular in the EU, on the carbon impact of technology. And I think it's quite a good opportunity for open source.

You know, we have very high transparency standards for us to meet those requirements, not necessarily to lower the emissions dramatically, but at least be transparent on the impact of the software.

Chris Adams: Yeah, I mean, this is actually, you touched on quite an interesting thing, which is both a link to some of the Mozilla work, but also, in the kind of AI world, which is kind of adjacent to us as like webby people. There's, I know that Mozilla provided a bit of funding to Code Carbon, which is an open source Python library for people to understand the environmental footprint of AI training, and I think these days some inference as well via the kind of Energy Score AI,

a project that they have with hugging face, for example. So the, you know, one of the reasons you have that is because, oh God, I'm gonna murder the name. There's a French supercomputer, Jean Paul. Jean. Oh, do you know the one I'm talking 

Thibaud Colas: No, I don't actually. 

Chris Adams: Okay. So maybe the thing I'll do is I'll give you a chance to respind to this

while I look it up, but I do know that one of the reasons we have any numbers at all for the, environmental footprint of AI was because there was a, you know, publicly funded, supported supercomputer with some work by, some people at hugging face, I forget, the Bloom model. 

Thibaud Colas: Oh, The Bloom 

Chris Adams: yeah. Yeah, exactly. That, we have these numbers and there was a paper produced to actually highlight this.

Because the supercomputer, the people who are running the super supercomputer are able to share some of these numbers where it's, where traditionally we've had a real challenge getting some of these numbers back. So that's one place where having some open examples, at least give us something like a proxy in the face of like not quite deafening silence from groups like Open AI and Anthropic and stuff like that, but we're not seeing that much in the way of numbers. And given that we're seeing this massive build out, it's definitely something we are, I'm very glad. It's useful to have like open source organization, open source projects, and some, other ways of funding this to actually at least create some data for us to have a kind of data informed discussion about some of this.

Thibaud Colas: A hundred percent. Yeah. This Bloom large language model is, I think really, it's really essential for us for, to see this research being done because then when, you know, people talk about adding AI in a CMS or in their Django projects, we can point them to understanding like, you know, what the potential increase in the carbon footprint of the project is, and yeah. You know, in the AI world, there's this whole debate about what open source means for AI models.

Definitely it's not, there's lots of gray areas there, but if you wanna reuse their research, it's much easier if there's just a underlying philosophy of open source and open data in those organizations.

Chris Adams: Jean Zay, that's the name of the supercomputer in France, which has this, there's actually ones in Boston as well. There is one over there. And the, in the US NREL, the National Renewable Energy Labs folks, they did, they've shared a bunch of information about this as well when they've got access to this, and this is actually providing a bit of kind of light to a discussion, which is mo mostly about heat so far it seems. So that's actually quite kind of useful. You've just made me realize that later on this year, this might be one of the angles that we might see people talking about the use of AI for actually drilling for oil and gas and other kind of stuff which is not great for climate because, NE, which is a nationally, it's a state owned.

NE is a state owned energy company in Italy. They are one of the few people who actually have a publicly owned supercomputer. And because Italy is one of the countries that signed the Paris Agreement, there's currently a whole law court case about essentially suing NE to say, well, if you are state owned and, this is, and you've signed this, why the hell are you actually now using AI to drill for oil and gas, for example? And this might be one of the ways that we actually see some numbers coming out of this. 'Cause since 2019, we know that there are companies which are doing things with this.

But for example, we know that say companies like Microsoft are involved in helping use these tools to kind of get oil and gas and fossil fuels out this out of the ground. But there's not much visible, there's not much out there right now since the press release has stopped in 2019, and it feels like it's a real gap we have when we talk about sustainability and technology, and particularly AI, I suppose.

Thibaud Colas: Yeah, that's really interesting for us to consider for Wagtail as well because, you know, we talk about the carbon footprint of the websites, but it's also important to consider what the website might be enabling or, you know, in positives and negatives. And, yeah, even beyond websites, when I've tried to, you know, take my work from Wagtail to Django and even the Python ecosystem at large, with Python, you have to reckon with the footprint of web services built with Python, but also of all the data science that supports this same, you know, oil and gas industry. So it's tricky.

Chris Adams: Yeah, I mean, we've just saw, like we're speaking on the 4th of June and we had there two days ago, and, we've seen like massive drone attack wiping out like a third of Russia's bomber fleet. Right. And that was basically like some Arduino drone pilot software was one of the key pieces that was used inside that.

And it's not necessarily like the open source developers, they didn't build it for that. But we are now seeing all this stuff show up and like we haven't figured out ways to kind of talk about where the responsibility lies or how you even think about some of this stuff. Because yeah, this takes the like,

we might have words like dual use for talking about these kind of technologies, but in a world of open source, it becomes much, much harder to figure out where some of these boundaries lie and how you actually, well, I guess, set some norms. I mean, maybe this is actually one thing. Yeah, I'll leave you some space then I wanna ask you a little bit about, you mentioned the wider Python ecosystem,

'cause I know that's something you've actually been having some conversations with as well.

Thibaud Colas: Yeah, well, connecting the dots, you know, it's also the usage, but also as contributors, you have to consider that maybe there are only so many people in the Wagtail or Django world

that are responsible for how the tech is put together. So maybe in some sense you do share some kind of responsibility personally for the tech you produced out there, even though you don't control how people will ue it. Which is, you know, a whole dimension of how you or how much you take ownership of that. And yeah, in the Python world more widely, you know, Python is the most popular language out there. Even if it might not be the most performance, even if there might be simpler languages that help you get more optimized, lower emissions software, people are gonna use Python in all sorts of ways.

And some of them, you agree with it, some you don't. I think that's one of the, you know, realities of open source contribution you have to be aware of.

Chris Adams: You've actually said something quite interesting about, okay, yeah, there's a limited number of people inside the Wagtail community and you've been able to have some success in like helping set some norms or helping help kind of set some directions there. And there's maybe a slightly larger group, which is like in the Django land, like when with you in the kind of acting as a president now, I know there's some interest that you have there. And there's groups that I've been involved with, right. But you also mentioned that there's a kind of wider Python ecosystem there, people talking about this, I mean, is this, if someone is actually looking, let's say they're coding on Python, they wanna find out who else is doing this. Like, is there someone you'd look, you'd point people to?

Or are there any conversations you're aware of going on right now?

 

Thibaud Colas: The Python ecosystem is big.

So one of the big challenges to get started with is just putting enough people together to have those discussions. 

I have tried on the Python discussion forum. I think it's, "who's working on sustainability in Python?" is the thread I put together. And I guess, I think, to me, what's important at this point is just getting tech people, you know, aware of the fact that we have this climate change challenge and that they can do something about it. And then, you know, realizing that open source has a role to play and as open source contributors we can very much move the needle. So in the Python world, you know, it's being so big and the uses being so different, there are lots of ways to help by working on the performance of Python itself, but there are also lots of ways to help outside that. Even something as simple, you know, as the Python Software Foundation trying to quantify their own organization footprint or the footprint of a conference like PyCon US, that can go quite a long way, I think.

Chris Adams: Cool. Thank you for that. Actually, I'm really glad you mentioned PyCon US because there were a number of, talks that I heard other people on other podcasts talking about it. They were really pleased to see. So there, there seemed to be some latent interest there. And what we could do is we'll share a link to some movie videos that were up there, because yeah, I was pleasantly surprised to see them when I saw PyCon's videos come up on YouTube because,

wow, it came up really fast. Like there is, you know, really nice things about like design pressure and how to think about like your code. But yeah, there's a few people saying who are totally new to, like, I've been, you know, the existing green software field, there are people who seem to be quite new to it talking about this.

So that's, that's encouraging.

Thibaud Colas: Yeah. And in some ways, you know, AI, the whole negative impacts of AI, the whole like problem and kind of forms for our whole industry, but with, you know, LLMs being so costly to train, so, you know, energy intensive to train in some ways it also helps people understand better the implications. Yeah, exactly.

And just build up awareness. So I think what you're referring to at PyCon US is, the work on

Chris Adams: Yes. 

Yeah. Thank you.

Thibaud Colas: Yeah, Machine Learning in Python, quantifying the energy impact of that and LM specifically. And, yeah, people like him, you know, he's involved with Google Summer of Code for Django, so

definitely in the position. Yeah. Yeah. And, I think it's just a, it's a matter of, for us as open source people of, nurturing, you know,

those areas of expertise. Making sure we have those people having the conversations and, yeah, also sharing them in a wider sphere of the industry at large.

Chris Adams: And I suppose, I mean, one of the other things is that pretty much all the people you've mentioned who are going through the Summer of Code stuff, these are people who are in one of the regions which you're seeing like 50 degrees Celsius heat waves and stuff like that. It, there's kind of like moral weight that comes from someone talking about, they say, "Hey, I'm experiencing this stuff and I'm in an area which is very much exposed to this" in a way that if you are in some way, you are somewhat insulated to, from a lot of these problems, it doesn't, it might not carry the same weight actually.

Wow. Thank you. I hadn't realized that.

Thibaud Colas: I really liked this parallel that one of my colleagues at Torchbox put together about our work in accessibility

and the war in Ukraine, talking about other big topics, where, you know, practically speaking, there is a war, it's horrendous, people are getting maims

and they don't necessarily have the same life after.

And if you invest in accessibility, means being be better able to support. people who go through the conflict with major harm and, yeah, I think it's quite important for us in open source, you know, when I, when Lauri talks about high impact contributions, to hark back to those values you might have about helping others and realize the connection, even though, you know, there are quite a few layers between me, a human contributor, and a Wagtail website, we can have that impact.

Chris Adams: Well, I guess that's the whole point of the web, right? The Web is, this is for everyone like London Olympics, Tim, I mean, Tim Berners-Lee, his like massive thing. "This is for everyone" being a kind of, okay, we're getting a bit teary and a bit, get a bit carried away ourselves and we're running short on time, so I should probably kind of wrap this up before we go too, far down that rabbit hole. Thank you so much for coming on for this. As we wrap up, are there any projects or things that you would like to draw people's attention to that you found particularly exciting of late before we wrap up?

Thibaud Colas: Definitely. I'd recommend people check out this Grid-Aware websites work that the Green Web Foundation puts together. 

Chris Adams: I did not tell him to say that. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. 

Thibaud Colas: He did not. But you know, it is actually really impactful in my mind to put together multiple CMS partners through this project and, on a personal basis, this type of project,

I was really skeptical of the benefits at the beginning, and it's really interesting to get your thought process starting on, yeah, like tangible ways to move the needle on new sites, but also existing ones. So specifically the work we're doing for this project, Google Summer of Code. I think we'll have results to show for it in about a month's time and hopefully it's reusable for other people.

Chris Adams: Yeah, there's actually, okay, now that you mentioned this, I've just gotta touch on it. There is actually a grid aware SDK, which is currently out there, and you can think of Grid Aware as being very aware, kind of like quite comparable to carbon aware, basically, but with a few extra different nuances.

The thing I should probably share is that this is actually work that has had a degree of funding from SIDN, which is a 

Dutch foundation that has been trying to figure out what to do in like greening the internet. So there are pockets of interest if you know who to speak to. And hopefully we should see more of these things kind of bearing fruit over the coming months.

Alright. I don't wanna spend too much time talking about that, because we're coming up to time. Thibaud, thank you so much for giving us your attention and time and sharing your learnings about, both in the word of Django, Python and in Wagtail. If people are curious about what you're up to, where should people look?

Thibaud Colas: I had, simply enough I'd love for them to join yet another thing you didn't ask me to mention, which is the Climateaction.tech Slack. this is my favorite place to, you know, have this tight-knit community of tech people working on this stuff. And just DM me there. And I'll be very happy to answer any questions about any of this or just get you started with your own projects. For me, specifically, otherwise in the Wagtail world, the Wagtail Newsletter is a good place to have this work come to you on a weekly basis. And, yeah, just LinkedIn otherwise.

Chris Adams: Brilliant. Thank you so much for this. I hope you have a lovely day and yeah. Hopefully we'll cross paths again soon. All right. Take care of yourself.

Thibaud Colas: Pleasure, Chris.

Chris Adams: Cheers. Okay, bye. 

 Hey everyone, thanks for listening. Just a reminder to follow Environment Variables on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And please do leave a rating and review if you like what we're doing. It helps other people discover the show, and of course, we'd love to have more listeners.

To find out more about the Green Software Foundation, please visit greensoftware.foundation. That's greensoftware.foundation in any browser. Thanks again, and see you in the next episode.