The podcast discusses the influence of Bertillon in ID card practice. Tracy shares her love for historical uprisings. They explore the ethics of data collection and face recognition. The hosts talk about the flaws and accomplishments of a historical figure. They discuss the evolution of the word 'Luddite' and worker uprisings.
Read more
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The podcast episode raises concerns about the unethical data collection practices of Alfonse Berteillon, who collected data without people's consent, including using family members and colleagues, which has implications for the use of data, like face recognition, in law enforcement.
Berteillon's work on identification systems, including mandating ID cards for the homeless in Paris, had a significant impact on the widespread use of mandatory IDs, despite criticism of his methods and biases.
Deep dives
Concerns about data collection without consent
One interesting aspect discussed in the podcast episode was the concern raised about the data collection practices of Alfonse Berteillon. It was pointed out that much of the data used in his system was collected without people's consent. This included using family members, colleagues, and even measuring people in prisons. The episode highlighted an article that explored the implications of using data, such as face recognition, in law enforcement without proper consent.
The role of identification cards
Another key point discussed in the podcast was the role of identification cards and how they originated from Berteillon's work. It was mentioned that Berteillon played a significant role in mandating identification cards for the homeless population in Paris. This was seen as the root of now widespread mandatory IDs in many places. The episode emphasized the impact of Berteillon's work on identification systems, even though his methods and biases faced criticism.
Berteillon's stubbornness and arrogance
The podcast also highlighted Berteillon's stubbornness and arrogance as a key aspect of his personality. Despite being respected as a genius, Berteillon struggled to acknowledge any criticism or admit when he was wrong. Examples were shared where he vehemently opposed suggestions, like the use of fingerprints, leading to conflicts and strained relationships. The episode suggested that Berteillon's self-perception and reluctance to accept differing opinions were likely influenced by his early experiences of feeling like an outsider or a black sheep.
Holly and Tracy discuss Bertillon's influence in the practice of people carrying ID cards. Tracy talks about how much she loves historical uprisings that include smashing things.