Chris Sutton, a former professional footballer, joins Rory Smith, chief football writer for the New York Times, Shay Given, an ex-Premier League goalkeeper, and Simon Stone, BBC's chief football news reporter. They dive into Tottenham's reputation as 'the ultimate fairweather team' after a recent loss. The discussion then shifts to Manchester City's legal battle with the Premier League, unpacking its significant implications. Lastly, the group debates the appropriateness of goalkeepers celebrating penalty saves, adding a lively twist to the conversation.
Tottenham's collapse against Brighton raises questions about their tactical adaptability and reinforces the perception of them as a fairweather team.
The verdict in Manchester City's legal case against the Premier League's APT rules could have significant implications for their financial future and governance.
The debate over whether goalkeepers should celebrate saving penalties highlights the emotional dynamics and pressures faced by players in high-stakes scenarios.
Deep dives
Nostalgia and Football Trading Cards
The discussion begins with a nostalgic trip down memory lane as one of the hosts shares a personal experience of going through old football trading cards from 1989 to 1990 with his son. This reflection not only highlights significant players from the era, such as Andy Hinchcliffe and Robert Rosario, but it also creates a sense of connection between past and present. The conversation humorously touches on the rarity of certain cards, like that of Chris Sutton, emphasizing the nostalgic value that football memorabilia holds for fans. The interlude serves to build rapport among the hosts while invoking shared memories of their football experiences.
Tottenham's Tactical Fragility
The panel examines Tottenham's recent performance, particularly their collapse in the second half against Brighton, prompting a discussion on their tactical vulnerabilities. A listener's email suggests that Spurs are the ultimate 'fair weather team,' thriving only when circumstances favor them, and unable to adapt when confronted with challenges. Rory Smith points out that while manager Ange Postecoglou has a clear vision for an attacking style of play, there are times when a more pragmatic approach is required to maintain control of a match. The group agrees that Spurs often struggle to adjust their tactics in crucial moments, raising questions about their ability to see out games under pressure.
Management Philosophy and Accountability
Ange Postecoglou’s unwavering commitment to his philosophy is analyzed, with Chris Sutton arguing that Tottenham fans initially appreciated this approach and the entertainment it brought. However, as the team settles into a new season, supporters may desire more pragmatic solutions in tense situations. The hosts discuss how Postecoglou’s willingness to stick to his ideals can sometimes leave the team exposed, particularly when they fail to adjust their game plan mid-match. They also note that while individual mistakes contributed to their defeat, the manager must take responsibility, as his approach influences how players execute their roles during times of adversity.
The 'Spursy' Legacy and Its Implications
The dreaded label 'Spursy' resurfaces in conversation, hinting at a long-standing reputation for inconsistency and fragility within the club. Shea Given suggests that labeling Postecoglou's team as Spursy after one loss might be unfair, especially since the team has demonstrated improved performances previously. Despite this, the hosts acknowledge that the 'DNA' of past underwhelming performances often appears to resurface during crucial moments, making it difficult for players to shake off such a mindset. This discussion highlights the psychological burden that historical perceptions can impose on both players and coaching staff in high-pressure situations.
Emotional Responses and Leadership in Press Conferences
The hosts navigate the nuances of managing emotions in the aftermath of a disappointing game, focusing on the importance of leadership in press interactions. They recount how Postecoglou's candid responses following the match reflect his passion for the game and responsibility as a manager. While some might argue that he needs to temper his honesty, others appreciate his straightforwardness and commitment to transparency. This dynamic suggests a delicate balance between showing vulnerability to supporters and maintaining accountability to players, as navigating media scrutiny becomes a significant aspect of modern football management.
Steve Crossman is joined by Chris Sutton, Rory Smith and Shay Given to discuss whether Tottenham are 'the ultimate fairweather team' after blowing a 2-0 lead to lose 3-2 at Brighton. The BBC's Chief Football News Reporter Simon Stone joins the pod to reflect on the verdict in Manchester City's legal case against the Premier League's associated party transaction (APT) rules and discuss what happens next. And the panel have a feisty debate over whether goalkeepers should celebrate saving penalties after Jordan Pickford thwarted Anthony Gordon on Saturday.
Topics:
02:58 - Are Spurs the ultimate fairweather team?
28:47 - What does the verdict in Manchester City's legal case against the Premier League's associated party transaction (APT) rules mean?
38:55 - Should goalkeepers celebrate saving penalties?
BBC Sounds / 5 Live commentaries this week:
Chelsea v Real Madrid - Women’s Champions League - 20:00 - Tuesday 8th October
Manchester City v Barcelona - Women’s Champions League - 20:00 - Wednesday 9th October
England v Greece - Nations League - 19:45 - Thursday 10th October
Arsenal v Chelsea - Women’s Super League - 13:45 - Saturday 12th October
Man Utd v Tottenham - Women’s Super League - 12:30 - Sunday 13th October
Finland v England - Nations League - 17:00 - Sunday 13th October
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode