The Crisis Room One in, one out: is this really a solution to the migrant crisis?
Jul 10, 2025
The podcast dives into the complexities of the ongoing migrant crisis, questioning if a 'one in, one out' policy will effectively address it. Insights are shared from government discussions on illegal migration and the push for high overall numbers. A debate arises over the potential implementation of ID cards as a solution, with opinions on privacy concerns. The conversation also touches on lessons from the Trump administration’s immigration strategies and explores the nomination of Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize, highlighting the intricacies of Middle Eastern diplomacy.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
2018 Channel Crossings Were Minimal
- When Amber Rudd was Home Secretary (2016-18), only 300 people crossed the Channel illegally by boat in 2018, compared to 20,000 this year.
- Illegal crossings then primarily involved concealed individuals in cars or lorries, detected using heat-seeking x-rays and assessments.
Immigration as Political Weapon
- The immigration debate is heavily politicized, used as a powerful political tool or weapon.
- Demonizing immigrants, like in the US with ICE raids, risks damaging social cohesion and community trust.
ID Cards Partly Effective
- ID cards could help reduce illegal immigration, but they won't eliminate black market work.
- ID cards are supportive but not a complete solution to the complex problem of illegal migration.