The latest food scandal in China reveals fuel tankers carrying cooking oil without cleaning, raising alarms about food safety. Past incidents like melamine-laced milk powder have dented public trust. As the middle class becomes more discerning, regulatory challenges and corporate practices are scrutinized. The discussion extends to the impact of these scandals on governmental credibility and the role of investigative journalism in promoting accountability. Amid these issues, the exclusive 'tergong' food supply for leaders highlights a stark divide in food safety perceptions.
Recent food safety scandals in China have heightened anxiety among the middle class, revealing deep concerns over health and trust in governance.
Investigative journalism uncovers food safety issues amidst censorship, highlighting the challenges of accountability and media freedom in China.
Deep dives
Concerns Over Food Safety Scandals
Recent food safety scandals in China, including the cooking oil crisis, have raised deep concerns among the Chinese middle class. The scandal revealed that trucks used for transporting cooking oil had not been cleaned properly and might have carried industrial fuel oil, alarming consumers. Such incidents are perceived as personal threats to health and safety, as they directly impact what people consume daily. This anxiety about food safety is not new, as China has faced similar issues over the past two decades, most infamously the melamine milk powder scandal, which adversely affected thousands of infants.
The Role of Media and Censorship
Investigative journalism has played a crucial role in uncovering food scandals in China, yet the media landscape is heavily controlled and often subject to censorship. Reports by reputable outlets like Beijing News can spark significant public discourse but also lead to consequences for journalists and their publications. After breaking the cooking oil story, the reporter involved faced repercussions, highlighting the precarious nature of journalistic work in China. This cycle of reporting and censorship raises questions about the effectiveness of media as a tool for accountability and public awareness.
Impact of Regulatory Gaps
The prevalence of food scandals in China can be largely attributed to regulatory gaps that fail to keep pace with rapid industrialization and market changes. Poor working conditions and low incomes among truck drivers, coupled with a demand for cost-cutting, often lead to compromised food safety practices. Local governments' motives to protect industrial interests hinder proper enforcement of existing regulations, allowing malpractices to persist. Consequently, these systemic issues reflect a broader problem of inadequate oversight and accountability in food safety management.
Public Response and Anxiety
The response among Chinese consumers to food safety crises illustrates a profound connection between food and public trust in governance. The intimate nature of food consumption breeds heightened anxiety, exacerbated by restrictions on public protest and accountability. While awareness of food safety issues spikes following scandals, it seldom translates into political action due to fear and repression. Ultimately, the inability to hold authorities accountable leaves the public feeling vulnerable to ongoing risks in food safety and quality.
Whenever I go back to China, I try to eat as much as I can – delicious Chinese food that I can’t have outside of the country, whether childhood favourites or the latest food trends. But I’m often struck by my relatives and friends who turn their noses up at many of these delicious dishes – they commonly say ‘不敢吃’ – ‘I’m scared to eat it’.
The Chinese middle class can now be very discerning about the food that they eat, and who can blame them? In the last twenty years, there seems to have been a steady stream of food safety and hygiene scandals – most infamously melamine-laced milk powder in 2008, which poisoned tens of thousands of babies. Since then, we’ve heard about pesticides being put into steamed buns to improve their texture, used cooking oil being retrieved from gutters to be reused, and lamb meat that might contain rat or fox.
The latest scandal, breaking over the last couple of months, is that of fuel tankers being used to carry cooking oil without the tankers being cleaned in between.
So what gives? Are these scandals a particularly Chinese phenomenon? Why hasn’t government regulation or punishment worked? And how does this impact political credibility in the eyes of the middle class?
I’m joined by two brilliant guests to discuss all of these questions and more.
Dali Yang is a political scientist and sinologist at the University of Chicago, whose research has focused on Chinese regulations when it comes to food and medicine. His latest book is Wuhan: How the Covid-19 Outbreak in China Spiralled Out of Control.
James Palmer is deputy editor at Foreign Policy and author of numerous books on China. He worked for years as a journalist inside China.