Catholic Answers Live

#12456 I’m Not Catholic Because I’m Hindu – Why Aren’t You Catholic? - Joe Heschmeyer

Nov 13, 2025
Joe Heschmeyer, a Catholic apologist and host of Shameless Popery, dives into why some Hindus resist Catholicism, addressing questions about modernism in faith. He challenges the concepts of reincarnation and past lives, providing a compelling view of the soul from a Christian perspective. The discussion touches on papal authority, Church teachings, and the balance of recognizing common ground with other religions while upholding core beliefs. Ultimately, Joe emphasizes that God's creation stems from love, desiring salvation for all.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Why Christianity Rejects Reincarnation

  • Catholics argue reincarnation conflicts with reason and Scripture because we lack memories of past lives and human numbers have not been fixed through history.
  • Joe Heschmeyer explains Scripture teaches each person dies once and then faces judgment, denying cyclical rebirth.
ADVICE

Define Terms Before Comparing Faiths

  • Clarify metaphysical terms when comparing faith traditions because words like 'soul' can mean different things across systems.
  • Ask what evidence would confirm claims like pre-existence or reincarnation before accepting their metaphysical implications.
ANECDOTE

Unexpected Kitten Turns Into Leo

  • Joe tells a story about unexpectedly receiving a kitten from friends as a house condition.
  • He describes naming the cat Leo after St. Leo following an online vote on Patreon and YouTube.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app