My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Rewind with Karen & Georgia - Episode 38: Sidebar Nation
Mar 26, 2025
Karen and Georgia take a nostalgic trip, sharing tales of a killer priest and the chilling Gage Park stabbings. They sprinkle in laughs from quirky gifts and humorous travel stories. The discussion dips into a gripping murder case intertwining family secrets with dark comedy. From the shocking murder of six family members to the lighter exchanges about self-care and comedy shows, the hosts balance humor with serious themes. They reflect on personal growth and invite fans to join the ongoing conversation.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
First Fan Encounter
- Georgia Hardstark was recognized by a fan in San Francisco who yelled "My Favorite Murder!" from a passing car.
- She was thrilled by the experience, marking a significant moment in the podcast's growth.
Unexpected Connections
- Karen Kilgariff recounts an interaction with director Peter Atencio, who recognized her from the "Nugatini" video.
- Atencio directed the video early in his career, showcasing unexpected connections.
Chicago Show Success
- My Favorite Murder sold out their Chicago Podcast Festival show with 950 attendees.
- Karen and Georgia's families express renewed interest in their work due to their success.