China’s Spiritual Revival and the Rise (and Fall) of Falun Gong — with Ian Johnson
Feb 20, 2025
auto_awesome
Ian Johnson, an award-winning journalist and Pulitzer Prize winner, discusses the complexities surrounding Falun Gong and its portrayal by the Chinese government. He highlights the spiritual revival in post-Mao China, revealing how disillusionment led to a surge in religious movements. Johnson shares personal anecdotes from his reporting journey and reflects on the challenges journalists face in addressing the controversial narrative of Falun Gong, calling for a nuanced understanding of cultural issues in the media.
The rise of Falun Gong in 1990s China reflects a broader spiritual revival as disillusionment with Maoist ideology encouraged exploration of alternative beliefs.
Falun Gong's complex portrayal as both a cult and a folk religion exemplifies the nuanced realities of spirituality amid political repression and stigma.
Journalistic approaches to covering Falun Gong highlight the challenges of balancing sensationalism with the need for nuanced, comprehensive narratives in media.
Deep dives
The Cultural Context of Falun Gong's Emergence
In the mid-90s, China's religious landscape was undergoing significant shifts as people sought alternatives to the discredited Maoist ideology after decades of hardship. The failure of Maoism to deliver prosperity left many disillusioned, prompting individuals to explore spiritual practices, including the rise of Falun Gong as a syncretic folk religion. This movement combined elements of Buddhism, Taoism, and local folk beliefs, resonating with a populace yearning for meaning. Concurrently, there was a notable revival of underground Christian sects, highlighting a broader trend of increasing spiritual exploration within the society.
The Complexity of Reporting on Falun Gong
Initially perceived by many as a cult based on government propaganda, Falun Gong's true nature was less clear-cut, requiring nuanced journalistic investigation. Through relationships with religious scholars and personal experiences, the journalist developed a more sympathetic understanding of Falun Gong as a reflection of historical religious practices in China. He noted that the movement was not unique but rather part of a long-standing tradition of folk religions that have persisted despite political repression. This understanding illuminated the unfair stigma associated with the group, fostering a belief that they deserved protection rather than persecution.
The Role of the Communist Party and State-Sanctioned Religiosity
Throughout the late 20th century, the Chinese Communist Party appeared to simultaneously suppress and embrace certain forms of spirituality, like Qigong, as a means of bolstering national identity. Senior leaders supported Qigong as a form of ‘Chinese science,’ and this legacy allowed movements like Falun Gong to flourish, albeit in unofficial circles. The Party's contradictory position created a space where practitioners could gather and share their beliefs in public parks while navigating the restrictions placed on more established religions. This backdrop ultimately shaped the environment in which Falun Gong could both thrive and attract the ire of the government when viewed as a threat to state authority.
Challenges and Triumphs of Investigative Journalism
The journalist's experiences at the Wall Street Journal helped refine his approach to storytelling, particularly during critical periods of Falun Gong's protests. Employing narrative non-fiction techniques, he strived to immerse readers in the realities faced by practitioners, capturing the human dimensions of their struggles. His rigorous approach involved deep investigations, verifying facts through secure communication channels, and engaging with multiple sources to gain comprehensive insights into the complexities of the movement. This method not only highlighted the protests' significance but also served as a model for impactful investigative journalism in a challenging environment.
Reflections on Reporting and the Role of Media
Reflecting on the past, the journalist emphasized the media's limitations in covering the broader realities of religious life in China, often focusing on negative news. Despite recognizing the need for more balanced narratives, he acknowledged the pressures inherent in commercial journalism, which typically favors sensationalism and urgent stories over nuanced exploration. The Pulitzer Prize awarded for his work on Falun Gong underscored how certain narratives become front-page news due to the severity of human rights abuses, often overshadowing the ongoing spiritual revival within the country. Through these experiences, he illuminated the importance of seeking diverse sources and perspectives to better understand complex issues such as religious movements in China.
Chasing the Falun Gong beat in Beijing and around China
Winning the Pulitzer
Recommended Readings:
David Ownby, 1996, Brotherhoods and Secret Societies in Early and Mid-Qing China, Standford Universit
Ian Johnson, 2004, Wild Grass, Pantheon
David A. Palmer, 2007, Qigong Fever, Columbia University Press
David Ownby, 2008, Falun Gong and the Future of China, Oxford University Press
Ian Johnson, 2017, Souls of China, Knopf Doubleday
Ian Johnson, 2023, Sparks, Oxford University Press
About us
The Peking Hotel podcast and newsletter are digital publications in which Liu He interviews China specialists about their first-hand experiences and observations from decades past. The project grew out of Liu’s research at Hoover Institution collecting oral history of China experts living in the U.S. Their stories are a reminder of what China used to be and what it is capable of becoming.
We also have a Chinese-language Substack. We hope to publish more conversations like this one, so stay tuned!
Thanks for reading Peking Hotel! This post is public so feel free to share it.