Acton Unwind

What Is Populism’s Place in American Conservatism?

Sep 11, 2023

The podcast episode delves into Mike Pence's speech on the dangers of populism and its contrasting with conservatism. They discuss the historical presence of populism, its influence on both sides of the political spectrum, and the need for a functional Congress. The panel also examines the connection between the Church of Scientology and the rape conviction of Danny Masterson. They explore concerns about other religions losing constitutional protections. Additionally, they reflect on the 22nd anniversary of September 11 and discuss Jimmy Buffett's music and concert experience.

01:05:39

AI Summary

AI Chapters

Episode notes

Podcast summary created with Snipd AI

Quick takeaways

Populism has always existed in American conservatism and on the left.

The passing of Jimmy Buffett leaves a void in the music world, but his legacy will live on through his music and the memories he created in the hearts of his fans.

Deep dives

Reflections on the 22nd anniversary of September 11th

The 22nd anniversary of September 11th is a reminder of the most generation-defining event in our lives. It was a moment that shattered our psyche and left us uncertain of the future. The aftermath of 9/11 has been filled with a mix of both positive and negative consequences, with changes in security measures becoming part of our daily lives. However, it seems that we are still fighting the last battle rather than preparing for potential future attacks. The rise of conspiracy theories and the spread of populism have also complicated the narrative around 9/11. Overall, it is a day to remember the lives lost, reflect on the ongoing impact, and consider the importance of forgiveness as a way to combat terrorism.

Introduction

3min

Mike Pence's Speech on Populism

13min

Subsidiarity in Electoral System

10min

Suspending the Constitution and Sentencing of Danny Masterson

5min

The Definition of a Church and the Church of Scientology's Relationship with Civil Authorities

3min

Religious Liberty in the United States

9min

Reflections on the 22nd Anniversary of September 11th

15min

Exploring Jimmy Buffett's Music and Concert Experience

7min

This week, Eric, Dylan, and Emily parse former vice president Mike Pence’s speech in New Hampshire, which was aimed at drawing distinctions between his definition of conservatism and the populism of the New Right and Donald Trump. Does Pence’s definition of the two in opposition to each other make sense? Or has populism always existed in American conservatism and on the left? Next, the panel looks at the implications for the Church of Scientology of the conviction and sentencing of former THAT ’70s SHOW co-star Danny Masterson to 30 years to life for rape. There are many people who would like to see Scientology lose its tax-exempt status and other constitutional protections, but what concerns should we have about the implications of those kinds of calls for other religions? And finally, the group reflects on the 22nd anniversary of September 11 and the passing of Jimmy Buffett.

Pence Calls Trump’s Populism a ‘Road to Ruin’ for the G.O.P. | New York Times

Conservatism vs. Populism Speech | Mike Pence for President

The Dream of Scalable Democracy | Dylan Pahman, Law & Liberty

Danny Masterson Sentenced to 30 Years to Life in Prison in Rape Retrial | TMZ

Leah Remini Rips “Criminal” Scientology in Aftermath of Danny Masterson Prison Sentencing | Deadline

A New York firefighter tells his story of 9/11 | Acton Line

Bombs, guns, and drones cannot win a spiritual war (UPDATED) | Dylan Pahman, Religion & Liberty Online

Jimmy Buffett, Roguish Bard of Island Escapism, Is Dead at 76 | New York Times