Quick Smart Why some politicians want us to feel 'ripped off'
Nov 10, 2025
David Rutledge, host of The Philosopher's Zone and a philosopher focused on democratic theory, delves into the precarious state of democracy today. He discusses how some leaders resemble monarchs and the dangers of disinformation. Rutledge explores Plato's skepticism about democracy and how societal fears can lead to voter apathy. He highlights the cultural shifts that made same-sex marriage possible and emphasizes the need for robust journalism to combat anti-democratic forces. Grassroots movements, he argues, are vital for preserving democratic values.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Plato’s Warning About Untrained Voters
- Plato (via Socrates) argued that untrained masses lack the skill to vote responsibly and risk disastrous governance.
- He warned democracies are vulnerable to demagogues who exploit public ignorance for power.
Enlightenment Cemented Democracy’s Dominance
- Democracy gained primacy in the West through the Enlightenment and associated liberal ideas.
- These ideas became so embedded that imagining alternatives feels almost impossible today.
Feeling ‘Ripped Off’ Undermines Solidarity
- People’s generosity at the ballot box depends on feeling secure and not ‘ripped off’.
- Politicians can manipulate fears about immigrants to shift voters toward punitive policies.
