In this special episode, the hosts discuss their framework for predicting NFL team success based on leadership. They analyze leadership in football teams, the importance of credible players and emotionally invested leaders, and the dynamic between coaches and quarterbacks. They explore the significance of galvanizers within teams and the concept of pot commitment. They also discuss the Pittsburgh Steelers' potential to exceed expectations, similarities between football and business, and using data points to evaluate success.
Strong leadership is a key factor for the success of NFL teams, as demonstrated by the Philadelphia Eagles' cohesive roster and high leadership rating of 13 out of 15.
The diverse leadership styles of successful coaches, such as Mike Tomlin, Andy Reid, and John Harbaugh, showcase the effectiveness of different approaches in achieving success.
Deep dives
High Leadership Scores: Philadelphia Eagles
The Philadelphia Eagles have emerged as a team with strong leadership, starting with Coach Nick Sirionny, who has steadily built the team up over the past three years. Quarterback Jalen Hurts also demonstrates leadership qualities, impressing with his work ethic and hard work. Additionally, the Eagles boast a roster filled with veteran leaders, including Jason Kelce, Lane Johnson, and Brandon Graham, along with a promising group of young players. With a leadership rating of 13 out of 15, the Eagles are projected to exceed expectations and potentially win 12 games this season.
Low Leadership Scores: Las Vegas Raiders
On the other end of the spectrum, the Las Vegas Raiders fall short in terms of leadership. Coach Jon Gruden has struggled as a head coach and lacks strong leadership skills. Quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo, recently acquired by the team, has never been seen as a leader by his previous teammates. The team's lack of veteran leaders further contributes to their low leadership rating of 5.5 out of 15. Las Vegas is predicted to win 7.5 games this year, but their weak leadership may result in an even worse performance.
Diverse Leadership Styles
The podcast highlights three coaches who received perfect leadership ratings and showcases their unique leadership styles. Mike Tomlin of the Pittsburgh Steelers is described as a players coach, deeply involved with his team and consistently overperforming. Andy Reid of the Kansas City Chiefs is known for his laid-back and creative approach, continuously pushing boundaries. John Harbaugh of the Baltimore Ravens strikes a balance between maturity and being a players guy, effectively guiding his team through challenges. These coaches demonstrate that diverse leadership styles can lead to success.
The Impact of Ownership and Continuity
The podcast emphasizes the importance of ownership and continuity in successful teams. Teams with strong owners, like the Pittsburgh Steelers and Baltimore Ravens, maintain stability, which positively influences the team's leadership and performance. On the other hand, teams like the Dallas Cowboys, whose owner also acts as the general manager, face challenges in building strong leadership due to a lack of separation and an overreliance on one person's decision-making. Continuity in leadership positions, both coaching and quarterback roles, also greatly impacts team success. Long-tenured coaches tend to develop their leadership skills over time, leading to more consistent performance.
This week - despite Tracy's best efforts - Pat and the fellas talk football. Tune in to this special episode for a breakdown of Pat's new framework for predicting the success of NFL teams based on their leadership.