The Evergetinos: Book Two - Chapter XLIII and XLIV

There is something terrifyingly honest in these stories because they do not allow us to hide behind good intentions or spiritual reputation. They expose how thin the veil is between holiness and destruction when the heart is not fully purified of anger and envy.

Florentius is not portrayed as weak or negligent. He is guileless. He prays. He fasts. He entrusts his life to God so completely that even a wild bear becomes obedient to the rhythm of his prayer. Creation itself recognizes innocence when the human heart is simple. The bear does not argue. It does not rebel. It returns at the sixth hour. It submits to fasting schedules. It becomes a brother. And then men who pray and chant psalms murder it out of envy.

The Evergetinos does not soften this. Envy is not a small flaw. It is demonic participation. The Devil enters precisely where comparison takes root. Their teacher does not work miracles. Another is becoming known. Something inside them twists. They do not attack Florentius directly. They kill what he loves. That is how envy works. It strikes sideways. It wounds through the innocent.

What follows should frighten anyone who thinks holiness gives permission to anger. Florentius prays for justice. He does not strike with his hands. He strikes with words. And heaven responds. The punishment is immediate. Public. Irreversible. And the most horrifying part is not the leprosy of the guilty monks but the lifelong repentance of the holy one whose prayer was answered.

Florentius spends the rest of his life calling himself a murderer.

That should stop us cold. God answers his prayer and Florentius is undone by it. He learns too late that the tongue can kill just as surely as a knife. Gregory is mercilessly clear. Revilers do not inherit the Kingdom. Not murderers. Not adulterers. Revilers. Those who curse. Those who wound with speech. Those who let anger become a prayer.

Then the Fathers press the knife deeper.

Makarios meets the same pagan twice. Once he is cursed and beaten almost to death. Once he blesses and converts a soul. The difference is not the pagan. The difference is the word. The disciple speaks truth without love and becomes an occasion of violence. The elder speaks love without flattery and becomes an occasion of resurrection. One word produces blood. Another produces monks.

An evil word makes even a good man evil. A good word makes even an evil man good. This is not poetry. It is spiritual law.

We want crosses without insults. We want asceticism without humiliation. We want holiness that never contradicts our self image. The Fathers laugh at this illusion. We behold the Cross and read about Christ’s sufferings and cannot endure a single insult without defending ourselves internally. Not even outwardly. In the heart. That is where the battle is lost.

Abba Isaiah is ruthless because he knows how fast anger multiplies. Do not argue. Do not justify. Make a prostration before your heart rehearses its case. Silence is not weakness here. It is warfare. If the insult is true repent. If it is false endure. Either way the soul is saved if the tongue is restrained.

The bear was obedient. The monks were not. The pagan ran in vain until he was greeted with mercy. Florentius learned that holiness without restraint of speech can still become an instrument of death. And the Fathers leave us with no escape. Words are not neutral. They either heal or rot the body of Christ.

This teaching burns because it strips us of our favorite refuge. We excuse anger as clarity. We baptize sharp speech as righteousness. We call curses discernment. The Evergetinos exposes this lie mercilessly. One word can unleash hell. One word can open the Kingdom.

The question is not whether we pray. The question is whether our words crucify or resurrect.

---

Text of chat during the group:

00:05:16 Fr. Charbel Abernethy: Page 336 Hypothesis XLIII

00:05:29 Fr. Charbel Abernethy: Philokaliaministries.org/blog

00:09:36 Fr. Charbel Abernethy: Page 336 Hypothesis XLIII

00:09:55 Fr. Charbel Abernethy: http://Philokaliaministries.org/blog

00:11:58 Fr. Charbel Abernethy: Page 336 Hypothesis XLIII Volume II

00:12:32 Angela Bellamy: What is the name of the book please?

00:12:45 Jessica McHale: Same here in Boston

00:13:06 Jerimy Spencer: Aloha Father, from a ‘chilly’ 78° O'ahu 😅

00:13:24 Jerimy Spencer: lol

00:14:26 Fr. Charbel Abernethy: https://www.ctosonline.org/patristic/EvCT.html

00:15:13 Angela Bellamy: I bought the Philokalia but the pages don't line up with your YouTube teaching.

00:23:13 Jerimy Spencer: Like the lion that helped dig and bury St Mary of Egypt ♥️☦️

00:24:34 Jessica McHale: Reacted to "Like the lion that..." with 👍

00:37:27 Jessica McHale: In all honestly, should we just endure verbal abuse?

00:39:46 Joan Chakonas: The ability to forgive /avoid cursing others goes along with not despairing of God forgiving us of our own accursed actions

00:40:47 Jerimy Spencer: Two thoughts, I’ve often thought that when someone murders, they murder something of their humanity, they assault the image of God within themselves…

And you’ve reminded me of the redemption of the Ransom character’s imagination from C.S. Lewis’ Space trilogy, where he begins to see reality as the two humans who kidnapped him from afar, at first thinks they are oddly shaped, sees them as alien and ultimately as villain.

01:03:23 Joan Chakonas: I think it’s hard to be good because insults or affronts come upon us suddenly  and it takes us by surprise

01:05:26 Joan Chakonas: It takes a lot of prayer and practice and grace eventually arrests our quick responses

01:07:12 John Burmeister: Im 61 and have been angry with people and said some stuff that i should probably have not said over these years. you make we wonder, that a lot of these people i did not know, we really will not know if we caused harm until after our death.

01:07:57 Jessica McHale: It's easier to take the insults of strangers, but when the insults are from family and you have no one--you're alone--it's hard not to become despondent or even engage in self-pity. We can identlfy with Christ in it--to be in the Garden of Gethsemance with Him, but it is a challenge. The worst part is not even the insults, it's knowing that if this person/people were living as a Christian their lives would be so much more peaceful and whole. The insults wouldn't even occur. That's the hard part to come to terms with. Praying and putting it in God's hands is best I guess.

01:12:04 Angela Bellamy: https://www.orthodoxroad.com/bless-my-enemies-o-lord/

01:27:16 Jessica McHale: Reacted to "https://www.orthod..." with ❤️

01:27:29 Ann’s iPad: Reacted to "https://www.orthodox…" with ❤️

01:28:32 Kevin Burke: Thank you Father, this teaching is a great blessing in my life.

01:28:38 Rebecca Thérèse: Thank you☺️

01:28:45 Jennifer Dantchev: Thank you!

01:28:49 Janine: Thank you Father

01:28:50 Bob Čihák, AZ: Thank you and bless you, Father.

01:28:53 Charmaine's iPad: Thank you

01:28:56 Andrew Adams: Merry Christmas everyone!

01:29:00 Jessica McHale: Bless you, Father--a thousand times! Merry Chistmas! Looking frward to Wednesday! Many prayers