Jen Roberts and Nitansha Bansal, both Assistant Directors at the Atlantic Council's Cyber Statecraft Initiative, dive into the intricate world of spyware. They reveal the dark corners of the global spyware market and its implications for national security and human rights. Exciting discussions include California's new deepfake laws aimed at curbing misinformation and the FTC's report spotlighting privacy lapses on social media. The guests emphasize the urgent need for regulatory oversight in a rapidly evolving digital landscape.
California's new laws on election-related deepfakes aim to promote transparency during campaigns while raising First Amendment concerns over free speech limitations.
The Cyber Statecraft Initiative's report on the global spyware market highlights the balance between legitimate security use and potential human rights abuses, advocating for stricter regulations.
Deep dives
California's Deepfake Legislation
California has enacted new laws addressing the use of deepfakes during election campaigns. One law prohibits the distribution of deceptive election-related deepfakes within 120 days leading up to an election and continues to apply for 60 days afterward. This unique provision aims to combat misinformation especially in the aftermath of elections, reflecting concerns from the recent electoral history. Other laws in the package mandate that political advertisements using AI-generated content must include clear labels, emphasizing transparency as a priority in combating deepfake misinformation.
First Amendment Challenges
The deepfake legislation raises significant First Amendment concerns, primarily due to its specificity regarding content-based restrictions on speech. Critics argue that such laws could be deemed overbroad, potentially infringing upon political speech and satire, which are crucial in democratic discourse. The government may assert a compelling interest in preventing voter deception; however, it must also demonstrate that the measures are narrowly tailored, which could prove challenging in court. The potential for judicial review could significantly impact the law's enforceability and constitutionality.
FTC Report on Social Media Surveillance
An FTC report highlighted inadequate privacy protections across major social media platforms, emphasizing the extensive surveillance of users, particularly minors. This staff report, though dry in presentation, points out systemic lapses in privacy controls and advocates for comprehensive privacy legislation to protect user data rights. Recommendations include clearer data collection policies and stringent rules for targeted advertising. This could serve as a crucial reference for lawmakers when formulating future regulations aimed at safeguarding consumers' privacy.
Insights from the Global Spyware Market Report
A report from the Cyber Statecraft Initiative provides an extensive overview of the global spyware market, identifying approximately 435 entities involved in its supply chain. It discusses the dual-use nature of spyware, which can serve legitimate national security purposes while also enabling human rights abuses. The report advocates for transparency in the spyware industry and recommends imposing stricter regulations on vendor disclosures and export licensing to prevent misuse. Political momentum is building to address these concerns, offering a hopeful trajectory for responsible governance surrounding spyware resources.
While this show covers legal topics, and Ben is a lawyer, the views expressed do not constitute legal advice. For official legal advice on any of the topics we cover, please contact your attorney.
Please take a moment to fill out an audience survey! Let us know how we are doing!
Get the weekly Caveat Briefing delivered to your inbox.
Like what you heard? Be sure to check out and subscribe to our Caveat Briefing, a weekly newsletter available exclusively to N2K Pro members on N2K CyberWire's website. N2K Pro members receive our Thursday wrap-up covering the latest in privacy, policy, and research news, including incidents, techniques, compliance, trends, and more.
This week’s Caveat Briefing covers California Governor Gavin Newsom's recent signing of three AI-related bills aimed at preventing the misuse of sexually explicit deepfakes. These new laws target AI developers and social media platforms, establishing regulations to prevent irresponsible use of the technology, while larger discussions around broader AI regulation continue as Newsom considers a major AI regulation bill pending his decision by September 30. Curious about the details? Head over to the Caveat Briefing for the full scoop and additional compelling stories.
Got a question you'd like us to answer on our show? You can send your audio file to caveat@thecyberwire.com. Hope to hear from you.