Steve Grumbine, founder of RealProgressives and host of Macro N Cheese, discusses the problems with Social Democracy, benefits of learning Marxist theory, and why Universal Basic Services is superior to Universal Basic Income. Topics include MMT, class analysis, and challenges within the Democratic Socialist movement.
Understanding Marxist theory benefits social democrats and MMT proponents.
Universal Basic Services is favored over Universal Basic Income for societal transformation.
The American Revolution's legacy highlights democratic challenges and property interests' influence.
Deep dives
The American Revolution Through a Critical Lens
The American Revolution, viewed in context, emerged as both radical and contradictory, with the bourgeoisie influencing a system designed for property-owning classes. Despite its revolutionary nature, it culminated in a carefully managed democracy favoring property interests. Critiques of founding on slavery and genocide acknowledge its significance within settler colonial countries, presenting a nuanced perspective amidst calls not to overlook the democratic potential the revolution unleashed.
The Unfinished Revolution and the Role of Democracy
The American Revolution's democratizing promise was undercut by property owners' dominance during the Constitution's formation post-Shays' Rebellion. Emphasizing the need for a socialist politics today, the hope for democracy remains pivotal. Acknowledging the democracy's hijacking by property interests prompts a call to uphold democratic ideals while navigating the systemic challenges
Contradictions and Class Interests in Governance
The establishment of a bourgeois republic post-American Revolution intertwined radical elements with authoritarian checks. The constitution's design favored property owners, leading to a 'perfectly managed' democracy. Challenges arise as property interests manipulate the system, hindering policies for the working class while sustaining dominance and control.
Navigating Ideological Tendencies and MMT Advocacy
Exploring ideologies on the left, the resistance to radical Marxist ideas underscores the push for modern monetary theory (MMT) adoption within social democratic factions. Assessing how MMT aligns with socialist inclinations, the podcast delves into the pragmatism vs. radicalism debate and the political barriers to progressive policies.
Toward Universal Basic Services (UBS) Over UBI
Proposing Universal Basic Services (UBS) over Universal Basic Income (UBI), the discussion highlights UBS as a transformative policy targeting systemic shifts. Differentiating UBS's societal impact from UBI's individual focus, the advocacy emphasizes UBS as a way to challenge existing power dynamics and address collective well-being over tokenistic reforms.
Support the show and get access to the Part 2 early on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/OneDime
In this episode of the 1Dime Radio podcast, I am joined by Steve Grumbine, founder of the RealProgressives non-profit and host of the Macro N Cheesepodcast, a podcast focused on Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) and left history. In this episode, we discuss the problems with modern Social Democracy and the Democratic Socialist movement (embodied in the DSA in America) and why social democrats and proponents of MMT would benefit from learning Marxist theory and a class analysis of politics. In part two, we discuss why Universal Basic Services (UBS) is a better policy than Universal Basic Income (UBI). Become a Patron to listen to it early!
Check out the Macro N Cheese podcast: https://www.youtube.com/@RealProgressives