Hamza Ali Shah, a British-Palestinian writer and journalist, discusses the lack of moral clarity surrounding the genocide in Gaza. Topics include the colonial roots of Israel's ethnic cleansing, failures of Arab state leaders, weaponization of ideology, and obfuscation of linguistic tricks that allow Israel to act with impunity. The podcast explores power dynamics in the Middle East, energy demands and power conflicts, settler violence, culture wars, and the exploitative nature of capitalism.
The crisis in Palestine is rooted in a lack of moral clarity and a disregard for Palestinian lives.
Access to resources, particularly oil and gas, plays a significant role in the Middle East conflict.
Israel's systematic oppression of Palestinians goes beyond the conflict with Hamas.
Deep dives
The Crisis in Palestine
The crisis in Palestine is rooted in a lack of moral clarity and a disregard for Palestinian lives. The international community has consistently failed to hold Israel accountable for its violence and oppression against Palestinians. Israel has strategically positioned itself as an attractive proposition for countries seeking business opportunities in the Middle East, despite its history of ethnic cleansing. The economic realm, driven by neoliberal capitalism, prioritizes profit over human rights. The crisis extends beyond Gaza to the West Bank, where settler violence, home demolitions, and military raids are ongoing. The West's complicity in the crisis can be attributed to vested interests, such as arms sales and resource extraction, that prioritize economic gains over human rights and justice.
The Role of Resources and Oil in the Middle East
Access to resources, particularly oil and gas, plays a significant role in the Middle East conflict. Saudi Arabia, for example, has situated itself as an attractive ally to Western countries due to its oil reserves. Similarly, Israel has made itself appealing by exploiting Palestinian ethnic cleansing. The economic and geopolitical interests of countries like the United States and the United Kingdom make them reluctant to hold Israel accountable for its actions. The pursuit of energy security and economic benefits drives their alliances and actions in the region. The West's approach to Palestine and Israel is characterized by double standards, as they prioritize economic and strategic interests over principles of justice and human rights.
The Systematic Oppression and Objectives of Israel
Israel's systematic oppression of Palestinians goes beyond the conflict with Hamas. The objective of Israel's policies is to ensure the dominance of a Jewish state. They seek to eliminate Palestinian resistance, erase Palestinian history, and maintain control over Palestinian territories. This objective is clear in the expansion of settlements, home demolitions, and settler violence in the West Bank, as well as collective punishments and military raids. The international community's failure to respond adequately allows Israel to act with impunity. By framing the conflict as a religious or ideological struggle, Israel justifies its actions and evades accountability. The complex power dynamics, economic interests, and historical context contribute to the ongoing crisis in Palestine.
The lack of international allies for Palestinians at the state level
The podcast episode discusses the lack of legitimate and robust international allies for the Palestinians at the state level. It highlights that while there is an outpouring of grassroots support and solidarity, the governments of various countries, including the US and the UK, do not take meaningful action to address the ongoing crisis in Palestine. This lack of action is seen as effectively complicit in the mass murder and oppression of Palestinians.
Manipulation of the narrative and weaponization of identity politics
The podcast also explores how the narrative surrounding the Palestinian-Israeli conflict is deliberately manipulated, often using identity politics, to pit communities against each other and to perpetuate divisions. It criticizes the conflation of Judaism with Zionism, emphasizing the need to separate critiques of the Israeli government from anti-Semitism. The episode argues for the importance of moral clarity and the need for accountability for those responsible for the suffering of Palestinians, advocating for holding individuals and governments to account through international courts and dismantling oppressive structures.
Ideologies are weaponised by the morally bankrupt to control those who are oriented towards values. Despite what the long arc of narrativised history would have us believe, even as it is being rewritten in realtime, the minority want more than their share—and they’ll do anything to take it. Wars are fought over resources; only the soldiers pray as dawn breaks.
Hamza Yusuf is a British-Palestinian writer and journalist. He joins me to discuss the establishment’s lack of moral clarity concerning the genocide taking place in Gaza. We discuss the colonial roots of Israel’s ethnic cleansing and the long history of Western forces’ desire to appropriate the immense fossil fuel resources of the Middle East. We also explore the failures of Arab state leaders to protect the Palestinian people, the weaponisation of ideology, and the deliberate obfuscation of linguistic tricks that see Israel acting with impunity on the international stage.
Planet: Critical investigates why the world is in crisis—and what to do about it. Support the project by becoming a free or paid subscriber.