Investor Spotlight: Brian Bustamante-Nicholson, Greycroft

In this episode of the Startup CPG Podcast, host Hannah Dittman sits down with Brian Bustamante-Nicholson, a partner at Greycroft in the consumer brands vertical, to explore what growth-stage investors actually look for in consumer businesses—and how founders can build with intention from day one.

Brian has spent 15 years working alongside founders building consumer businesses, developing a sharp lens for what actually drives durable growth versus what just looks good in a pitch deck. His experience spans deep e-commerce knowledge and evaluating brands at the earliest stages through to scale, giving him a practical, operator-minded view of how products, teams, and metrics evolve over time. At Greycroft, Brian leads a separate consumer investment strategy alongside founding entrepreneurs Catherine Power (Avaline, Burst, Merit) and Eric Ryan (Method, Olly), investing in exceptional growth-stage consumer businesses at inflection points—typically $5-15M in revenue with strong product-market fit signals.

Throughout the conversation, Brian shares the core pillars he looks at during diligence (velocities, cohort behavior, repeat purchase rate, unit economics, margin structure), why capital efficiency matters more than flashy growth, and how strategics evaluate businesses the same way investors do—making gamesmanship around metrics a losing strategy. He discusses lessons learned from standout portfolio companies like Array (anti-aging hair care), what strong founders consistently get right for long-term success, and how to think about building real defensibility as you grow—particularly the importance of retail distribution as a moat in oversaturated categories like health and wellness, skincare, and beverage.

Brian also shares his perspective on how AI is beginning to meaningfully show up in the consumer space through agentic commerce (AI agents shopping on consumers' behalf), why building digital footprints and distribution today will benefit brands tomorrow, and why being a first adopter in platform shifts creates outsized advantages through better marketplace economics. Whether you're navigating business decisions or fundraising conversations, this episode offers grounded, thoughtful insights on how investors evaluate consumer businesses and what it takes to build enduring brands that compound over time.

Listen in as they discuss:

• Brian's background: 15 years investing from Stripes Group to Sonoma Brands to Greycroft's consumer strategy
• What Greycroft looks for: $5-15M revenue, strong product-market fit, unit economics, margin structure
• Portfolio case study: Array anti-aging hair care and investing at inflection points
• Why capital efficiency matters: strategics see through gamesmanship around margins and growth
• Retail distribution as a moat: differentiation in oversaturated digital-native categories
• How AI is changing commerce: agentic shopping and building trust with AI agents through reviews and digital footprints
• Lessons learned: patience, concentrated strategies, and building enduring businesses with strong fundamentals
• Fundraising process: relationship-building timelines and how many meetings before closing deals

Episode Links:

Brian Bustamante-Nicholson - Partner, Greycroft
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/brian-b-nicholson-a813372/

Greycroft Website: https://www.greycroft.com
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/greycroft-partners/

Don't forget to leave a five-star review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify if you enjoyed this episode. For potential sponsorship opportunities or to join the Startup CPG community, visit http://www.startupcpg.com

Show Links:

• Transcripts of each episode are available on the Transistor platform that hosts our podcast here (click on the episode and toggle to “Transcript” at the top)
• Join the Startup CPG Slack community (30K+ members and growing!)
• Follow @startupcpg
• Visit host Hannah's Linkedin 
• Questions or comments about the episode? Email Daniel at podcast@startupcpg.com
• Episode music by Super Fantastics