The podcast explores the UK's new extremism definition and its impact on free speech. They discuss the controversy around racist comments by a top Tory donor affecting Rishi Sunak's leadership. Also, Labour's plans post-Brexit and proposals to improve government efficiency are highlighted. The episode delves into party funding dynamics and the challenges of addressing racism in politics.
New extremism definition in the UK raises concerns about free speech and legitimate organizations.
Complexity of extremism definition sparks debates over cultural issues and reshaping governance dynamics.
Labour proposes a security pact with the EU to rebuild relations post-Brexit and enhance collaborations.
Deep dives
The Government's New Definition of Extremism
The government has introduced a new definition of extremism aiming to identify and restrict groups considered too extreme to engage with. Communities Secretary Michael Gove highlighted the importance of avoiding past mistakes by supporting organizations promoting hate ideologies. The definition targets those supporting violent ideologies undermining fundamental rights of the United Kingdom as a liberal democracy. This move reflects ongoing concerns about addressing threats and influences perpetuating extremist actions.
Challenges and Controversies Surrounding the Extremism Definition
The government's definition of extremism includes individuals fostering atmospheres conducive to violent ideologies, sparking debate over its complexity and implications. Critics argue that the definition's expansiveness may encompass cultural debates like reproductive rights issues, posing political challenges. The policy aims to capture influences inspiring, rather than directing, terrorism, broadening its scope to combat nuances beyond traditional terror threats. Delving into cultures of intimidation, the definition seeks to reshape advisory dynamics across different levels of governance.
Tory Party Donor Controversy
Frank Hester, a significant Conservative donor, faced backlash following accusations of making racially charged remarks against MP Diane Abbott, igniting a substantial predicament for the Conservative Party. The party grapples with addressing the racist allegations against Hester while navigating the challenge of potentially returning his substantial donations. The handling of the situation by Chancellor Rishi Sunak faced scrutiny, leading to criticisms of the party's response strategy.
Labour's Strategic Approach Towards the EU
Labour is exploring innovative strategies to rebuild relations with the EU by emphasizing a new security pact to strengthen ties and future collaborations. The proposed security pact aims to extend cooperation across multiple aspects like economic security, environmental policies, and crime prevention, presenting a unique approach to reconnect with the EU post-Brexit. This strategy leverages security as a focal point to enhance engagement and navigate broader EU alignment discussions.
Institute for Government's Proposals for Government Restructuring
The Institute for Government recommends a restructuring of the government center, advocating for the dissolution of the Cabinet Office to refine operational efficiency. This proposed reform seeks to transfer civil service functions from the Cabinet Office to a specialized department focused on government reforms. Additionally, the report suggests streamlining the Cabinet to establish a smaller core group for strategic decision-making, aiming to enhance policy cohesion and effectiveness within government operations.
The UK government is redefining extremism. But there are warnings that the new guidance could curb free speech and ensnare legitimate organisations. The FT’s Lucy Fisher is joined by colleagues Robert Shrimsley and Stephen Bush to discuss the pushback from multiple Tory factions and Labour. They also dissect the row over racist comments allegedly made by the Conservatives’ biggest donor, and how it has prompted questions about Rishi Sunak’s leadership. Plus, Hannah White from the Institute for Government joins the panel, outlining a new plan designed to make it easier for future prime ministers to get things done.
Clip: BBC
Follow Lucy on X: @LOS_Fisher, Robert @robertshrimsley, Stephen Bush @stephenkb
Sign up here for 30 free days of Stephen Bush's Inside Politics newsletter, winner of the World Association of News Publishers 2023 ‘Best Newsletter’ award.
Presented by Lucy Fisher. Produced by Audrey Tinline with Leah Qiunn. Manuela Saragosa is the executive producer. Audio mix and original music by Breen Turner. The FT’s head of audio is Cheryl Brumley.
