Carah Burrell, a former Mormon missionary and the creative force behind the Nuance Hoe YouTube channel, joins John Dehlin to unpack the complexities of Joseph Smith's legacy. They dive into the invasive topic of polygamy, exposing hidden truths about Smith's marriages and the emotional fallout for followers. The discussion reveals the struggles of questioning deep-seated beliefs and the significance of transparency in faith. Carah's firsthand insights provide a unique lens into the evolving perceptions of church history and personal journeys of belief.
01:33:55
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
question_answer ANECDOTE
Eve's Faith Crisis Journey
Eve shares her personal struggle deconstructing faith while dealing with postpartum anxiety.
She trusted Kara's logical approach which helped break down her walls to question Mormon history.
insights INSIGHT
Joseph Smith's Secret Polygamy
Joseph Smith secretly married 30 to 40 women despite public denials.
Emma was sealed to him after 20+ other wives, violating the Law of Sarah revelation.
insights INSIGHT
Coercion and Polyandry in Polygamy
Joseph Smith coerced young women to marry him under threat of their family's eternal salvation.
His polygamy included marrying underage girls and wives of faithful church members (= polyandry).
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
B.H. Roberts' "No Man Knows My History" is a monumental work of Mormon history, offering a comprehensive account of the life and teachings of Joseph Smith. The book delves into Smith's early life, his religious experiences, and the development of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Roberts presents a detailed narrative, drawing on a wide range of sources and offering a critical perspective on the historical record. The book is considered a classic of Mormon scholarship and has influenced generations of historians and theologians. It is known for its meticulous research and its insightful analysis of the complex historical context of early Mormonism. The book's impact on the understanding of Mormon history is undeniable.
Rough Stone Rolling
A Biography of Joseph Smith
Richard Bushman
Richard Lyman Bushman's "Rough Stone Rolling" offers a detailed and insightful biography of Joseph Smith, the founder of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. The book delves into Smith's life, exploring his religious experiences, his leadership of the early church, and the controversies surrounding his life and teachings. Bushman presents a balanced and nuanced portrayal of Smith, acknowledging both his strengths and weaknesses. The book is considered a significant contribution to the historical understanding of Mormonism and its founder. It challenges traditional narratives and encourages critical engagement with the historical record. Bushman's work has been praised for its scholarly rigor and its accessibility to a broad audience.
In Sacred Loneliness
In Sacred Loneliness
Todd Compton
Todd Compton's "In Sacred Loneliness: The Untold Story of the Polygamy in the Early Mormon Church" offers a detailed account of Joseph Smith's plural marriages. The book delves into the lives of the women who were involved, providing insights into their experiences and perspectives. Compton's research draws on a wide range of historical sources, including personal journals, letters, and legal documents. The book challenges traditional narratives surrounding polygamy in the early Mormon Church, offering a more nuanced and complex understanding of this controversial practice. It raises important questions about power, gender, and the complexities of religious belief.
Join us as we revisit this epic interview with John Dehlin and Carah Burrell, which originally aired on Carah's channel in 2023.
Eve, a good friend of Carah Burrell's, was an active and faithful member of the LDS Church at the time of this interview. She had begun to question aspects of the Church—particularly polygamy—and agreed to sit down with Carah and John for a truly unique conversation. In this interview, they simply presented her with factual information about LDS history and captured her real-time reactions.
This one-of-a-kind interview is now being shared on Mormon Stories Podcast for the very first time. Be sure to join us later this week as Eve returns to the podcast—this time with both of her parents, who have experienced their own faith journeys since Eve's original interview two years ago.
Mormon Stories Podcast 
