Catholic Answers Live #12193 Did Paul’s Rebuke of Peter Undermine the Papacy? - Joe Heschmeyer
May 13, 2025
In this discussion, Joe Heschmeyer, the author of *Pope Peter*, delves into the intriguing dynamics between Paul and Peter, particularly Paul’s rebuke of Peter in Galatians. He tackles common objections to the papacy, explaining why Peter’s leadership remains vital despite moments of scandal. The conversation also explores interpretations of Peter's role, the biblical support for papal authority, and the significance of early Church governance. Heschmeyer sheds light on pivotal moments that shape our understanding of papal continuity and authority.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Papacy Is Church's Distinctive Doctrine
- The papacy is the Church's most distinctive doctrine but not necessarily the most important.
- If the papacy is true, Christians should be Catholic; if false, no one should be Catholic.
Biblical Doctrine Beyond Words
- The idea that everything important is spelled out in the Bible alone is false.
- Key doctrines like the papacy are understood through Scripture's meaning, not exact words.
Peter's Servant Leadership Role
- Jesus shows Peter’s unique leadership by appointing him to strengthen the brethren.
- Church leadership is servant leadership, not earthly power, exemplified by Peter’s role.
