The rise of the "super-council" - plus, assisted dying interview with Kim Leadbeater
Feb 14, 2025
auto_awesome
Rachel Cunliffe, Associate Political Editor for the New Statesman, and Megan Kenyon, a Policy Correspondent known for her insightful reporting, join to discuss significant local council changes in the UK. They delve into claims that the merging of councils, dubbed 'super-councils,' could undermine democracy and voters’ rights. Additionally, Megan interviews Kim Leadbeater about the pressing topic of assisted dying legislation, addressing safeguards and the balance between choice and coercion in this sensitive debate.
The postponement of local elections for nine councils highlights concerns over democratic input and potential political manipulation favoring Labour.
The debates surrounding the Assisted Dying Bill reveal significant tensions between legislative progress and the protection of vulnerable individuals' rights.
Deep dives
Local Council Elections and Devolution Plans
The decision to postpone local elections for nine councils is primarily driven by new devolution plans which aim to merge district and county councils into unitary authorities. This is intended to streamline local governance and provide more power at a local level, but many residents feel disenfranchised as their councils opted for these changes without direct input from the community. Though local councils applied for the change, the perception remains that residents were not adequately consulted. The effectiveness of such unitary authorities remains uncertain, as past reorganizations have led to financial difficulties in some regions.
Political Dynamics and Local Elections
The postponement of elections has created a complex political landscape, particularly favoring Labour due to the unfavorable conditions for the Conservative Party. Incumbent councils—over 300 being Conservative-held—stand to benefit from the delay as these elections could potentially return a majority for Labour, which is already gaining traction. The situation illustrates how changing the electoral calendar can serve as a strategic maneuver for political advantage. Additionally, the repercussions for smaller parties like the Liberal Democrats are particularly notable, as it reduces their opportunities to contest previously held Conservative seats.
Assisted Dying Bill and Legislative Safeguards
The proposed amendments to the Assisted Dying Bill have sparked debates about the adequacy of safeguards in the decision-making process for assisted dying. The initial requirement for High Court oversight is under scrutiny, with discussions now favoring an expert panel as a possible alternative to ensure comprehensive scrutiny. Critics argue that removing judicial oversight may compromise the integrity of the legislative safeguards meant to protect vulnerable individuals from coercion. The tense discussions surrounding the bill reflect the broader concerns of ensuring a balance between legislative progress and the protection of individual rights.
Parliamentary Process and Public Sentiment
The negotiation surrounding the Assisted Dying Bill illustrates the unique challenges of advancing contentious legislation through a private member's bill. Continuous debates raise questions about both the timing and depth of scrutiny this issue is receiving, with Members of Parliament expressing varying degrees of support and skepticism. The process has been marked by calls for more thorough consideration, with many MPs sharing concerns about rushing the decision-making and the implications for public trust in the system. As legislative processes evolve, they reveal how public sentiment can shape political discourse and influence legislative outcomes.
Are local council changes "an attack on democracy"?
Rachel Cunliffe and Megan Kenyon join Hannah Barnes to discuss changes to the rules governing local elections, which Ed Davey and Nigel Farage have attacked as anti-democratic. They answer a listener question about why their local council can "delay my right to vote".
Also in this episode, Megan Kenyon meets Kim Leadbeater for an update on the assisted dying bill, and we answer your questions about the checks and balances that would apply if the bill were to pass.
Submit a question for us to answer on a future podcast: www.newstatesman.com/youaskus
Get our free daily politics newsletter, Morning Call: morningcall.substack.com
Subscribe to the New Statesman. Get your first five weeks for just £5 at www.newstatesman.com/feb25