S2E26 Feminism Against Progress: A Conversation with Mary Harrington
Jun 6, 2023
auto_awesome
Reactionary feminist Mary Harrington discusses the history of feminism, her journey from proponent to radical opponent of progress, the impact of technology on women and society, and her new book, Feminism Against Progress.
Progress has taken on a quasi-theological turn, leading to a belief that things will always get better, but it may not necessarily result in the overall improvement of human well-being according to Mary Harrington.
The lost tradition of the feminism of care, which focused on the value of women's roles as caregivers and mothers, has been largely overlooked or dismissed in contemporary discourse.
The internet has transformed self-perception and identity, leading to disembodied social paradigms and a transhumanist turn, which raises concerns about the privatization of sexuality and the commodification of the human body according to Mary Harrington.
Deep dives
The essence of feminism against progress
Mary Harrington argues that progress is not a universal truth and that feminism should be arranged against progress in its current form. She asserts that progress has taken on a quasi-theological turn in contemporary culture and politics, leading to a belief that things will always get better. However, Harrington questions this belief and argues that progress has not necessarily resulted in the overall improvement of human well-being. She states that feminism should be focused on defending women's interests in their specific material and cultural contexts, rather than subscribing to a universalized notion of progress.
Exploring the lost tradition of the feminism of care
Harrington delves into the history of feminism and uncovers a lost tradition known as the feminism of care. This tradition, she argues, emerged in response to the transformation of family life brought about by the Industrial Revolution. It advocated for the value of women's roles in the domestic sphere and sought to address the specific interests and needs of women as caregivers and mothers. However, this dimension of feminism has been largely overlooked or dismissed in contemporary discourse, leading to a narrow focus on the feminism of freedom.
The relationship between economic ideas and womenhood
Harrington explores the link between economic ideas and the perception of women's roles in society. She critiques the influence of libertarianism in shaping feminist ideology, particularly the cyborg feminism that emerged after the second wave. This ideology, she argues, views the human body and sexuality as commodities to be controlled, traded, and modified. Harrington points out the consequences of this perspective, such as the normalization of the sex industry and the commodification of human bodies. She calls for feminism to reclaim its critique of capitalism and explore alternative perspectives on women's interests in an increasingly technologically driven world.
The impact of the internet on self-perception
Harrington examines the transformative impact of the internet on how people perceive themselves. She describes the internet as a place where individuals exist beyond their physical bodies. The ability to create anonymous and alternative selves online has influenced notions of identity and freedom. Harrington highlights the rise of disembodied social paradigms and the transhumanist turn in contemporary culture, which she connects to the privatization of sexuality and the commodification of the human body. She raises concerns about the impact of the internet on self-perception and the need to navigate its effects on personal well-being and society as a whole.
Reflections on the challenges and possibilities ahead
Harrington acknowledges the complexities and contradictions surrounding feminism, progress, and technological advancements. She recognizes the challenges posed by the internet and the need to find ways to live with it while mitigating its negative effects. Harrington emphasizes the importance of questioning the dominant narratives surrounding feminism and technology, and calls for a critical examination of the future. She urges a reclamation of feminism, a reevaluation of progress, and a nuanced understanding of the relationships between technology, societal values, and women's interests.
Is feminism compatible with progress? Reactionary feminist Mary Harrington thinks not. In this interview, she discusses the history of feminism, her own journey from proponent to radical opponent of progress, the impact of technology on women and society, and, of course, her new book, Feminism Against Progress (Regnery, 2023).
Mary Harrington is a contributing editor at UnHerd and widely-published essayist. You can her book, Feminism Against Progress here.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode