Raz Zimmt, a senior researcher at the Institute for National Security Studies and an expert on Iranian dynamics, shares keen insights on Iran's collapsing proxy system. He discusses how Iranian leaders view their nation’s historical legacy and its influence on foreign policy. Zimmt explores the psychological lessons from the Iran-Iraq War and the regime's vulnerability amid rising unrest. Additionally, he addresses the internal debate on nuclear ambitions amidst increasing military pressures, highlighting the significant role of hardliners in shaping Iran's strategic paths.
Iran perceives a strategic military balance with Israel through new missile capabilities, yet grapples with internal dissent and economic instability.
The regime's historical trauma from the Iran-Iraq War shapes its aggressive posturing while confronting the dual challenges of legitimacy and external threats.
Deep dives
Iran's Perception of Military Balance
Iran has recently developed ballistic missiles and drones, leading its leadership to believe they have achieved a strategic military balance with Israel. This perception of newfound capabilities has prompted Tehran to act with increased confidence, believing they can circumvent previous conventional weaknesses. The context of the Iran-Iraq War continues to shape their thinking; the memory of being attacked without able defense instills a national urgency to maintain deterrence. This historical trauma influences Iranian leadership, fostering a narrative that they are encircled by hostile forces, which in turn justifies aggressive postures against perceived threats.
The Impact of the Syrian Conflict
The fall of Assad's regime has reinvigorated discussions within Iran regarding its vulnerability and reflects the fragility of authoritarian regimes. This swift collapse serves as a cautionary tale for Iranian leaders, who recognize the potential for rapid regime change under pressure. Internally, the Iranian regime is dealing with widespread public dissatisfaction due to economic mismanagement and external pressures, complicating its stability. As protests and calls for change gain momentum, leaders are internally debating how to maintain legitimacy while avoiding the fate of Assad.
Internal and External Pressures on Iran
Iran is grappling with significant economic challenges, including high inflation and budget deficits, alongside a crisis of legitimacy that diminishes public support. Surveys indicate that fewer than 25% of Iranians actively support the regime, revealing a disconnect between the government's actions and the needs of its citizens. Fenestration against Israel and regional adversaries remains vital; however, widespread discontent domestically weakens the regime's military posture as it faces both internal dissent and external threats. The challenge remains for the regime to suppress internal opposition while balancing its focus on foreign policy.
Strategic Options for Iran Moving Forward
Iran faces several strategic options in a rapidly evolving geopolitical landscape that could define its policy direction. The first option is to focus on domestic governance and address pressing internal issues, reducing external engagement while stabilizing the economy. Another path involves continuing support for regional proxies and enhancing military capabilities, though this comes with the risk of escalation with Israel. The most drastic choice would be pursuing nuclear capabilities, which could offer Iran a formidable deterrent, but would heighten the risks of confrontation with Israel and the United States, leading to further isolation and instability.
Over the past few months, and especially in recent days, we have seen Iran’s decades-old proxy system and strategy collapsing.
What are Iran’s options?
To help us understand how Iran is dealing with this crisis, our guest is Raz Zimmt, one of Israel’s top experts on Iran.
Raz Zimmt is a senior researcher at the Institute for National Security Studies (INSS) and a research fellow at the Center for Iranian Studies at Tel Aviv University. He is the author of the book "Iran From Within: State and Society in the Islamic Republic" published (in Hebrew) in 2022.
Recent published pieces by Raz Zimmt discussed in this episode: