Dive into the quirky connection between Donald Trump's anti-Deep State rhetoric and the plight of the Atlantic herring. Unpack the shifting narratives around regulation, particularly the rollicking ride of the Chevron doctrine. Discover the implications of Schedule F on federal jobs and how Trump’s return might reshape bureaucracy. Explore the clash between government dysfunction and the need for competence in public health and environmental safety. Finally, navigate the complicated landscape of legal interpretations and corporate influences in federal regulation.
The concept of 'deep state' evolved from scrutiny of Trump to a broader critique of federal bureaucracies viewed as obstacles by conservatives.
The Supreme Court's ruling in Loper-Bright vs. Raimondo signals a pivotal shift, diminishing agency power and increasing judicial control over regulatory interpretations.
Deep dives
Understanding the Deep State
The term 'deep state' has evolved significantly since its introduction during Donald Trump's presidency. Initially, it described scrutiny of his actions, particularly regarding the Mueller investigation into Russian electoral interference. Over time, it transformed into a broader critique against the federal administrative state, appealing to conservative activists and corporate interests who perceive it as a hindrance to their agendas. The deep state, as used in contemporary political discourse, alludes to government bureaucracies that critics assert operate independently and oppose the will of elected officials.
The Administrative State Explained
The administrative state refers to federal agencies essential for overseeing regulations and ensuring public welfare. These agencies, like the EPA and FDA, possess the expertise necessary to create and enforce rules concerning environmental standards, food safety, and more. However, corporate interests view these agencies as obstacles to business, leading to extensive lobbying against regulations and efforts to appoint judges who favor deregulation. The concept of the administrative state highlights the crucial role federal agencies play in safeguarding citizens against public health and environmental risks.
Chevron vs. NRDC: A Landmark Decision
The case of Chevron vs. NRDC established a precedent that allowed federal agencies considerable leeway in interpreting ambiguous laws, effectively granting them deference in regulatory matters. This decision became a cornerstone of agency power, recognized for acknowledging the expertise that agency professionals possess in complex fields. However, it also became a target for conservative groups who have long sought to diminish the administrative state’s reach. Over the years, as the regulatory landscape expanded, this deference made it increasingly difficult for corporations to successfully challenge regulations, culminating in growing discontent within business circles.
The Implications of the Loper-Bright Case
The Supreme Court's decision in Loper-Bright vs. Raimondo overruled the Chevron precedent, signaling a substantial shift in how courts will approach regulatory authority. This landmark ruling emphasized that courts, rather than agencies, should determine interpretations of federal laws, potentially leading to a flood of litigation regarding agency regulations. The ruling is seen as a significant win for conservative interests, who argue that it limits what they perceive as an unchecked power of the administrative state. As a result, the ruling raises concerns about the future efficacy of regulatory protections, as it shifts decision-making power from specialized professionals to the judiciary.
What’s the connection between former President Donald Trump's attacks on the so-called “Deep State" and a tiny silvery fish? The Supreme Court, of course.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode