Why American Democracy is in Danger, with Michael Beschloss
Nov 1, 2024
auto_awesome
Michael Beschloss, a renowned presidential historian and NBC News contributor, discusses the crucial and perilous crossroad the U.S. faces leading into the 2024 election. He starkly compares it to historic turning points, warning that Donald Trump's rhetoric aligns with fascism. Beschloss emphasizes the fragility of democracy and the possibility of resistance through civic engagement and state autonomy, igniting an urgent conversation about the roles of character and leadership in safeguarding democratic values.
The 2024 election is viewed as a critical turning point for American democracy, comparable to historical elections on the brink of crisis.
Michael Beschloss highlights the alarming normalization of extreme political rhetoric, raising concerns about public desensitization to fascist ideologies.
The conversation underscores the necessity of civic engagement and robust education to safeguard democracy against authoritarian threats.
Deep dives
Impact of the Upcoming Election
The conversation emphasizes the weightiness of the approaching 2024 presidential election, portraying it as a pivotal moment for American democracy. The uncertainty surrounding the election evokes feelings of anxiety among the hosts, illustrating how the political climate affects their emotional state. They express hope that women voters might play a crucial role in determining the outcome, reflecting on the potential implications of this election on the country's future. The hosts also ponder the historical context, considering how election results could redefine America's democratic journey.
The Normalization of Extreme Political Rhetoric
Discussion highlights how political discourse has shifted, particularly with Donald Trump's candidacy, where extreme statements have become more common. The sharing of alarming anecdotes, including claims about Trump's admiration for historical fascism, showcases the unsettling normalization of radical rhetoric in American politics. Michael Beschloss’s thoughts reflect concerns about Americans becoming desensitized to extreme comments from political figures, which could diminish the significance of such statements. The importance of recognizing these trends as dangerous precedents for democracy is underscored.
Historical Context for Current Political Dynamics
The dialogue draws parallels between contemporary political phenomena and historical events, using examples from the past to inform present concerns. Michael Beschloss discusses the significance of historical rallies, including parallels to Trump’s events, which evoke powerful images of national division. He stresses the critical nature of understanding these historical references as they resonate with current political actions and ideologies. This context is crucial to grasping the ongoing threat to democratic values and the potential resurgence of fascist ideologies.
The Role of Democracy and Civil Society
A central theme emerges regarding the fragility of democracy and the importance of civic engagement in safeguarding democratic values. The hosts explore the decline of civics education and its consequences on the electorate's understanding of democracy. Michael Beschloss emphasizes that history teaches resilience and the importance of active participation to maintain democratic integrity. This discussion suggests a call to action for citizens to reinforce their roles in advocating freedom and resisting authoritarian tendencies.
What Lies Ahead for Future Elections
The conversations reflect on the uncertainty of future political elections and how they may continue to shape the American political landscape. The discussion hints at a possible realignment in American parties and the emergence of voter coalitions that could defy traditional political categorization. There is an awareness that polarization may not diminish but rather evolve in response to societal changes. Ultimately, the hosts convey a sense of urgency for voters to remain engaged and proactive in this changing political environment.
The Washington Roundtable discusses the 2024 election with the historian Michael Beschloss, before a live audience at The New Yorker Festival, on October 26th. He calls this election a “turning point” as monumental as the election of 1860—on the eve of the Civil War—and that of 1940, when the U.S. was deciding whether to adopt or fight Fascism. “I think Donald Trump meets most of the parts of the definition of the word fascist,” Beschloss says. “You go through all of American history, and you cannot find another major party nominee who has promised to be dictator for a day, which we all know will not be only for a day.” But, if Trump does return to the White House, he adds, there is still hope that the rule of law, public protest, and the presence of state capitals free of federal domination will allow the U.S. to resist autocracy.
To discover more podcasts from The New Yorker, visit newyorker.com/podcasts. To send in feedback on this episode, write to themail@newyorker.com with “The Political Scene” in the subject line.