Power, Play, Sex And Food: An Alternative History of Rome
Aug 22, 2023
auto_awesome
In this engaging discussion, Peter Stothard, a former editor of The Times and author of "Palatine: An Alternative History of the Caesars," reveals fresh insights on ancient Rome's emperors and their entourages. He analyzes how food and power shaped public perception, contrasting lavish banquets with the simplicity faced by the populace. Stothard also addresses the often biased historical narratives surrounding women and explores the evolution of Roman identity. Plus, dive into the legacy of emperors marked by gluttony in the wake of political turmoil.
Food played a crucial role in ancient Rome, serving as a power tool used by emperors to manipulate public perception and showcase imperial dominance.
The transition from outdoor politics to indoor rule transformed Rome's political landscape, ushering in a bureaucratic system and leaving a lasting legacy in the form of a palace-centered power structure.
Deep dives
The Importance of Food as a Power Tool in Ancient Rome
Food played a crucial role in ancient Rome as it was used as a power tool. Roman emperors, such as Augustus and Tiberius, carefully curated their public image by portraying themselves as simple eaters, consuming basic foods like eggs and apples. This was done to create a connection with the common people and show empathy for those who often faced hunger. However, behind closed doors, emperors indulged in extravagant banquets and luxurious foods, which served as imperial statements to showcase their dominion over conquered territories. The deception surrounding food was deeply rooted in the understanding that well-fed people were different from those constantly at risk of hunger. This contrast between public and private consumption demonstrated the power dynamics and theatrical conceit of the imperial period.
The Transformation of Rome with the Shift From Outdoor Politics to Indoor Rule
The transition from outdoor politics to indoor rule was a significant turning point in Rome. Initially, political power was intertwined with public spaces such as the streets and forum. However, as Rome evolved, political power became centered in the Palatine, a house that eventually gave rise to the concept of a palace. Moving inside ushered in a new era, where power dynamics and skills required for domestic environments became vital. The factors contributing to power, such as food and flattery, shifted from their outdoor manifestations to internal manipulations. This transition led to the emergence of a bureaucratic system, where power relationships were interlocked, and a bevy of individuals ranging from slaves to ex-slaves to wives had their role within the system. Consequently, moving inside not only transformed Rome's political landscape but also left a lasting legacy in the form of bureaucracy.
The Role of Reputation and Flattery in Roman Society
Reputation played a vital role in Roman society, and maintaining legitimacy was key for those in power. A person's legitimacy relied on whether their predecessor depended on them for legitimacy. For example, Emperor Tiberius, who succeeded Augustus, preserved his reputation by not tarnishing the image of Augustus or the women in his court. On the other hand, those who succeeded without this dependency, like Nero, often denigrated their predecessors to establish their own legitimacy. Women also faced challenges as their power increased within the household while becoming subjects of scandalous and scandalous stories. The legacies of individuals and their reputations were shaped by the interplay of flattery, manipulation, and power dynamics within the Roman elite.
The Transformation of the Palatine Hill and the Rise of the Vitellius Family
The Palatine Hill, known as the center of imperial power, underwent significant physical and symbolic transformations throughout Roman history. Augustus strategically integrated the existing houses on the hill, avoiding the construction of a grand palace and maintaining connections to the public through the construction of a public temple to Apollo. However, the Palatine eventually evolved into a private and exclusive space with darker corridors and increased privacy. Following a devastating fire in Rome, Emperor Nero constructed the extravagant Golden House, symbolizing his power and status. Within this context, the Vitellius family, particularly Lucius Vitellius, emerged as skillful bureaucrats and flatterers. Lucius gained prominence as a diplomat and skillfully dealt with rulers like Caligula, using wit and clever responses. The family's rise to power and subsequent negative reputation, particularly that of gluttony and excess, left a lasting impact on how the Imperial era was perceived.
The annals of ancient Rome’s first emperors have been recounted countless times. However, in his new book, Palatine: An Alternative History of the Caesars, former editor of The Times Peter Stothard presents a fresh perspective. Stothard shifts the focus to the individuals who orbited around figures such as Tiberius, Caligula, and Claudius – the courtiers, flatterers, slaves, former slaves, gluttons and party animals who formed their entourage. He joins our host, fellow classicist Daisy Dunn, to share his insights.
We’d love to hear your feedback and what you think we should talk about next, who we should have on and what our future debates should be.
Send us an email or voice note with your thoughts to podcasts@intelligencesquared.com or Tweet us @intelligence2.
And if you’d like to get ad-free access to all Intelligence Squared podcasts, including exclusive bonus content, early access to new episodes and much more, become a supporter of Intelligence Squared today for just £4.99, or the equivalent in your local currency .
Just visit intelligencesquared.com/membership to find out more.
