Asheesh Kapur Siddique, "The Archive of Empire: Knowledge, Conquest, and the Making of the Early Modern British World" (Yale UP, 2024)
Feb 19, 2025
auto_awesome
Asheesh Kapur Siddique, an assistant professor of history at UMass Amherst and author of "The Archive of Empire," dives into how the British Empire utilized archives to govern its vast territories. He discusses the crucial interplay between knowledge management and colonial expansion, revealing how written records shaped political orders. Siddique highlights the evolution of archival practices, the complexity of integrating diverse legal systems, and the transition of archives from secrets to public records, emphasizing their modern implications.
The British Empire's governance relied heavily on written records and information management to control diverse territories and populations.
Archives became crucial for understanding power dynamics, revealing how different groups, such as Native Americans and Indians, were variably documented.
Deep dives
The Role of Information in Early Modern Empires
The podcast emphasizes the importance of information management in the governance of early modern empires, particularly the British Empire. The use of technologies like paper and parchment was crucial, as these materials were employed to keep track of vast distances and complex political structures. Dr. Ashish Kapoor Sadiq explores how officials relied on written records to communicate directives and evaluate compliance among local administrators. This intricate process of documentation became essential for maintaining control over distant territories and understanding local dynamics.
Reimagining Archives and Their Contents
The discussion highlights how historians view archives as reflections of power dynamics, particularly regarding whose voices are represented. For example, Native Americans were often treated as diplomatic entities rather than British subjects, which affected how they were documented in official records. Conversely, Indians in British-controlled territories were considered subjects, leading to more extensive data collection about their lives and governance. The podcast illustrates the varying representations of marginalized groups in archival materials, helping to illuminate the complexities of empire.
The Interaction Between Governance and Written Records
Another key point addressed is the exchange between governance and the proliferation of written records within imperial structures. The East India Company and the Board of Trade implemented systematic documentation practices to monitor and report on their activities, thus entrenching bureaucratic norms. However, this bureaucratic process often led to frustrations, as officials were required to submit repetitive reports, reflecting the ongoing tension between centralized control and local administration. This complex relationship reveals how records were both tools of governance and potential sources of conflict among imperial officials.
Archives Transitioning from Secrecy to Public Access
The podcast also discusses the evolution of archival access, as historical documents moved from secretive spaces to public availability in the 19th century. This shift is seen as a pivotal moment where the perspective on archives transitioned from being instruments for immediate governance to resources for historical research. Such changes were influenced by growing public demand for information and the idea of transparency in government. By the mid-19th century, policies were established that allowed broader access to archival records, laying the groundwork for modern archival practices.
Over the span of two hundred years, Great Britain established, governed, lost, and reconstructed an empire that embraced three continents and two oceanic worlds. The British ruled this empire by correlating incoming information about the conduct of subjects and aliens in imperial spaces with norms of good governance developed in London. Officials derived these norms by studying the histories of government contained in the official records of both the state and corporations and located in repositories known as archives.
As the empire expanded in both the Americas and India, however, this system of political knowledge came to be regarded as inadequate in governing the non-English people who inhabited the lands over which the British asserted sovereignty. This posed a key problem for imperial officials: What kind of knowledge was required to govern an empire populated by a growing number of culturally different people? Using files, pens, and paper, the British defined the information order of the modern state as they debated answers to this question. In tracing the rise and deployment of archives in early modern British imperial rule, in The Archive of Empire: Knowledge, Conquest, and the Making of the Early Modern British World (Yale University Press, 2024) Dr. Asheesh Kapur Siddique uncovers the origins of our data-driven present.
This interview was conducted by Dr. Miranda Melcher whose new book focuses on post-conflict military integration, understanding treaty negotiation and implementation in civil war contexts, with qualitative analysis of the Angolan and Mozambican civil wars.