#STRask If Sin Is a Disease We’re Born with, How Can We Be Guilty When We Sin?
Jun 19, 2025
Explore the fascinating concept of original sin likened to a disease, questioning our guilt when born in sin. Delve into how free will exists in Heaven without the ability to sin, suggesting a profound connection between our desires and true freedom. The discussion tackles Euthyphro's Dilemma, pondering whether morality is dictated by God's will or reflects His innate goodness. The interplay of goodness and logic is also examined, inviting listeners to consider if these truths are divinely decreed or independently valid.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Sin Is a Fallen Character Flaw
- Sin as a disease is a faulty metaphor because diseases lack moral responsibility.
- Our sinfulness is a fallen character flaw for which we are culpable because we choose to act on it.
Lord of the Rings Evil Analogy
- The "Lord of the Rings" example illustrates evil born as inherent nature, not a choice.
- The evil creature killing its midwife on birth reflects humanity's fallen sinful nature.
Free Will Without Sin in Heaven
- Free will in heaven means choosing freely but only desiring good, not sin.
- Like God, heavenly freedom excludes sin by nature, not by inability.