Challenging History Erasures to Expand Possible Futures
Dec 13, 2023
auto_awesome
The podcast explores the impact of storytelling on collective memory, the dangers of manipulating historical accounts, the intersection of storytelling, infrastructure, and history, the connection between millenarian Marxism and neo-Christian vision in Silicon Valley, the collision of old myths and new technologies, unity and diversity in debating the past in democracy, and the importance of civil debate and diverse stories.
Preserving historical accuracy is crucial to prevent false narratives from shaping people's views and actions.
Art and literature play a vital role in embodying the experiences and aspirations of society, providing deeper insights into the impact of false realities.
Physical and material infrastructures, along with personal storytelling, are key in countering the erasure of historical narratives and preserving memory.
Deep dives
Importance of Preserving Historical Accuracy
The podcast episode discusses the significance of preserving historical accuracy in the face of false narratives. The guest, Abby Smith-Rumsy, expresses her frustration with the divisions in the United States during the Trump era and emphasizes the dangers of playing around with historical accounts. She highlights the importance of understanding the fragility of memory and the potential for false realities to shape people's views and actions. Rumsy draws parallels between her experiences in the former Soviet Union and the current political landscape, stressing the need for a truthful understanding of the past to prevent the tampering of collective reality.
The Role of Artists and Novelists in Preserving History
Abby Smith-Rumsy and Fred Turner discuss the role of artists and novelists in preserving history and memory. Rumsy explains how Russian artists and writers used their works to embody the lived experiences and moral aspirations of a society lacking free political discourse. She contrasts this with American art, suggesting that an examination of art and literature can provide a deeper understanding of subjective evidence and the impact of false realities on daily lives. Rumsy and Turner also reflect on the importance of craftsmanship, beauty, and the ability to attract attention in effectively communicating ideas to an audience.
Infrastructures of Memory and the Challenges of Erasure
The podcast delves into the concept of infrastructures of memory and their importance in countering erasure. Rumsy discusses the significance of physical and material infrastructures such as libraries, books, and institutions in resisting the elimination of historical narratives. She highlights the powerful impact of individuals and storytelling in preserving memory, even in the absence of official institutional support. The conversation also touches on the tension between tightly written narratives and open-ended historical explanations, emphasizing the need to embrace chance and contingency in understanding the past. Additionally, the role of guilt and innocence in shaping memory and the possibilities of positive memory editing are explored.
Importance of understanding oral transmission of memory
Understanding the way memory is transmitted orally in certain cultures, particularly African American cultures, is crucial for historians. It is necessary to go beyond relying solely on text-based evidence and gain a better understanding of human memory and its biological processes. Historians should also explore the growing field of material evidence and have a better grasp of the source base they work with, including its preservation and the role of librarians.
The power and potential of self-recording and individual stories
The availability of digital technologies and self-recording tools allows individuals to share their own stories. Historians should embrace this wealth of stories rather than dismissing them, as subjective evidence can provide valuable context and insights. By analyzing a diverse range of stories, historians can understand the contingencies and structures that shape specific contexts and offer a deeper understanding of societal dynamics. This focus on personal narratives can help counter the dangers of ideological narratives and promote self-determination and a more nuanced interpretation of history.
Two-time CASBS fellow Fred Turner engages CASBS board of directors chair Abby Smith Rumsey before a live audience to discuss her new book "Memory, Edited: Taking Liberties with History." When the erasure or distortion of collective memory through storytelling hijacks fact, truth, and history itself, what kind of information infrastructures can effectively confront those false narratives? Turner and Rumsey explore the tensions between history and storytelling and resulting implications for political beliefs, actions, and our collective sense of reality.