

Ep. 363: Franz Brentano's Moral Epistemology (Part One)
4 snips Mar 17, 2025
Delve into Franz Brentano's fascinating insights on moral epistemology. Discover how he argues that certain preferences are innately good, beyond cultural influences. The discussion explores the origins of moral truths and critiques inherent moral principles. Unpack the complexities of moral intuitionism and the relationship between instinctual behavior and ethical reasoning. The hosts tackle the independence of moral truth from societal norms, encouraging a deeper understanding of ethics through phenomenology.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Brentano’s Moral Intuitionism
- Brentano embraces moral intuitionism, arguing we can rationally sense rightness in preferences with certainty.
- This approach opposes pure empiricism and traditional rationalism, emphasizing direct moral experience.
Habituation Precedes Moral Insight
- Proper moral insight requires habituation through education and social conditioning.
- Innate impulses alone do not guarantee an understanding or appreciation of the good.
Self-Evidence Requires Justification
- Brentano distinguishes self-evidence from obviousness, emphasizing justification in moral knowledge.
- True self-evident truths allow rational explanation, separating them from mere beliefs.