Discussing the debate between price and value in arts and culture, questioning the ethics of selling experiences, the role of government funding in ensuring access for all, and the societal significance of cultural events. Panelists explore the impact of state subsidies, career choices, and the bias in measuring arts success, raising questions about the necessity of public funding for the arts.
The podcast debates the ethical implications of pricing art above just value, questioning its impact on societal accessibility and fairness.
Participants discuss the challenges of balancing public funding for popular and niche art forms, highlighting the need for diverse artistic support.
The conversation explores the complex relationship between state subsidies, artistic freedom, and cultural enrichment, emphasizing the importance of a diverse and inclusive arts ecosystem.
Deep dives
The Debate Over State Subsidies for the Arts
The podcast discusses the tension between the value of state subsidies for the arts and the concerns regarding creative freedom and financial support for artists. It delves into the ethical considerations of using public funds to support art in society, weighing the benefits of cultural enrichment against potential constraints on artistic expression and political biases within the arts sector.
Accessibility vs. Funding Challenges in the Arts Sector
Discussions center on the accessibility of art and cultural experiences to diverse socioeconomic groups and the challenges of public funding allocation in the arts sector. The conversation explores the balance between supporting popular art forms accessible to the general public and preserving heritage or less mainstream art that may struggle to attract private patronage.
Impact of State Subsidies on Artistic Freedom and Diversity
The dialogue addresses the impact of state subsidies on artistic freedom, diversity, and the potential constraints faced by artists. It contemplates the balance between creative expression, financial support, and societal demands within the arts landscape.
Debating the Role of Public Subsidy in Artistic Expression
Participants reflect on the role of public subsidy in fostering artistic expression, cultural engagement, and social impact. They consider the challenges of defining and measuring the value of art, the need for varied funding sources, and the importance of nurturing a diverse and inclusive arts ecosystem.
Navigating Impartiality, Value, and Public Perception in the Arts
The conversation delves into the complexities of balancing artistic value, public perception, and the concept of impartiality in the arts. It addresses the challenge of justifying state subsidies for art based on societal impact, financial sustainability, and the intrinsic value of cultural enrichment.
Taylor Swift fever has swept the UK week. She’s back in August and fans have been paying hundreds sometimes thousands to get their hands on seats through resale sites. It’s led us to think about the price and value of art and culture. St Thomas Aquinas came up with the ‘just price’ theory, that it is wrong to sell something for more than it is worth and charging more based on the need of the buyer is exploitative and sinful. Is that what is going on when punters are asked to stump up for a once in a lifetime experience?
In Latin the word pretium means both value and price, but the two are not interchangeable when it comes to the arts. How can you put a price on a potentially transcendent experience, or the life changing power of art? Is that what makes good art and is that what is worth paying for? Do live events culture have a value in itself aside from the economic impact? What does it mean for society when people are priced out? Should governments pick up the bill to make sure everyone has access to the arts. Or are they just an indulgence, a nice way to spend your leisure time but not something deserving of funds in comparison to global problems like poverty or malaria.
Presenter: Michael Buerk
Panel:
Inaya Folarin-Iman
James Orr
Professor Mona Siddiqui
Matthew Taylor
Witnesses:
Christopher Snowdon, Head of Lifestyle Economics at the IEA
Professor Mel Jordan, Professor of Art and the Public Sphere, Coventry University
Matt Reardon, Advisor at 80,000 Hours
Professor Paul Gough, Vice Chancellor of the Arts University Bournemouth
Presenter: Michael Buerk
Producer: Catherine Murray
Assistant Producer: Ruth Purser
Programme Co-ordinator Nancy Bennie & Pete Liggins
Editor: Tim Pemberton
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode