Dive into the intriguing world of the Hashemite dynasty, tracing its roots from the Ottoman Empire to modern-day politics. Discover the ideological clash between monarchism and republication amid ongoing tensions over the Temple Mount. Explore the complex identity of Iraq through the lens of sociologist Ali Alwardi and the tumultuous journey to independence. Learn about key figures like Nuri al-Said and the aftermath of the assassination of King Abdullah I, revealing the profound impact on Arab nationalism and the evolving landscape of the region.
The podcast explores the historical significance of the Hashemite monarchs in Iraq and Jordan following the Ottoman Empire's decline.
It emphasizes the ideological clash between traditional monarchy and modern Arab republicanism, illustrating the resultant conflicts and power struggles.
Recent tensions in Jerusalem are analyzed, revealing shifts in Arab public sentiment and the implications for regional political dynamics.
Deep dives
The Hashemite Legacy and Regional Dynamics
The history of the Hashemite monarchs in the Arab region, particularly in Iraq and Jordan, is explored in depth. Following the fall of the Ottoman Empire, the Hashemites were given control of both Jordan and Iraq, creating a significant challenge as modern Arab republicanism emerged as a counterforce to traditional monarchy. The ideological battle between these two forms of governance has led to ongoing conflicts and rivalries that can still be felt today. The episode highlights how the Hashemites navigated these challenges, often resorting to drastic measures to preserve their power amid the rise of competing pan-Arab ideologies.
Current Conflicts in Jerusalem
Recent clashes in Jerusalem are scrutinized, highlighting the tensions between Israeli forces and Palestinian protesters on the Temple Mount. The violence, which erupted ostensibly due to provocative actions by religious extremists, revealed underlying tensions linked to broader political struggles, including aspirations for a renewed intifada. Observers note a notable shift in the reaction of the Arab world, with muted outrage compared to previous escalations, indicating potential changes in public sentiment among Gulf Arabs. The discussion raises questions about the role of youth activists and their motivations, as well as the implications for regional stability and historical grievances.
The Collapse of the Hashemite System
The demise of the Hashemite monarchy in Iraq is contextualized against a backdrop of rising nationalism and anti-colonial sentiment. In 1958, a violent revolution led by military officers resulted in the execution of King Faisal II, marking the end of Hashemite rule in Iraq. The episode discusses how this radical shift was influenced by external factors, including the popularity of Nasser's pan-Arab ideals, leading to a significant realignment of power in the region. The narrative reflects on the brutal nature of the revolution and the chaos that ensued as Iraq transitioned into a military dictatorship.
Nouri al-Said and Iraqi Politics
Nouri al-Said's role as a key figure in Iraqi politics during the formation of the modern state is critically examined. Throughout the 1920s to the late 1950s, al-Said navigated complex political landscapes, often aligning with British interests, which ultimately eroded his popularity. His tenure witnessed rising opposition movements, influenced by discontent with British policies and socio-economic disparities across ethnic and religious groups. Despite his initial successes, the culmination of dissent led to his demise alongside the monarchy during the 1958 revolution.
Transnational Ideologies and Their Impact
The episode reflects on the influence of transnational ideologies, particularly Arab nationalism and communism, which profoundly affected the political dynamics in the Middle East. These ideologies fostered a sense of unity among diverse opposition groups, ultimately contributing to the unravelling of monarchies in the region. The contrast between the desire for unity under these ideologies and the reality of fragmented national identities culminated in significant internal strife and external pressures. The discussion illustrates how contemporary politics continues to grapple with the legacies of these movements and their enduring impact on national governance.
As we race toward the 1967 and 1973 Arab-Israeli wars, we’re putting our final duck in its row. After the fall of the Ottoman Empire, Jordan and Iraq both received Hashemite monarchs—and the rivalries and ideological conflicts that followed still reverberate today, perhaps nowhere more powerfully than on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem. Focusing mainly on the tragic history of modern Iraq, this episode engages with the clash between modern Arab republicanism and something like traditional monarchism (Aimen’s favourite!), as competing versions of Pan-Arabism violently spread throughout the region, prompting the Hashemites into ever more desperate acts of self-preservation.
Listen to exclusive bonus content and get all episodes ad-free by subscribing to Conflicted Extra on Apple Podcasts and Spotify for just 99p/month.
Join our FB Discussion group to get exclusive updates: https://www.facebook.com/groups/450486135832418
Find us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/MHconflicted
And Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/MHconflicted
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Join the Conflicted Community hub on Discord to discuss all things Conflicted with fellow dear listeners, get exclusive content, bonus episodes and ad-free listening. Register your interest through the link: http://www.levellr.com/conflicted