Should I Stay or Should I Go? Why Staying in the Church Might Be the Most Subversive Act - w/ Dr. Timothy Gombis

When the rot of power, celebrity, and capitalism runs deep in modern American church culture, is walking away the best response—or is there another way forward? In this deeply vulnerable and passionate installment of the New Creation Series, Mike Erre and Tim Stafford are joined by theologian Dr. Timothy Gombis, who brings sobering wisdom, theological insight, and a dawning vision of church grounded not in success but in rest, repentance, and resistance.

What begins as an honest lament about megachurch scandals, celebrity abuse, and American idolatry evolves into a provocative reimagining of what it truly means to be the Church. Rather than retreat into cynicism or fight to fix a broken system with the same tools that corrupted it, Gombis invites us into a radical posture: Sabbath rest, confession, humble presence, and quiet faithfulness. Together, the trio confronts questions about church size, performative faith, historical injustice, and the seductive pull of power—all through the lens of New Creation.

Key Takeaways: • Deconstructing Celebrity Church – Confronting the spiritual costs of megachurch models built on personality, PR, and performance. • Reimagining Church Participation – How simply being the church may be more transformative than trying to fix the church. • Capitalism & the Gospel – Why American success metrics have co-opted the church and how reframing our goals changes everything. • Receiving the Kingdom – Embracing the Gospel’s passive verbs: inheriting, receiving, and resting instead of striving and producing. • Practices of Peace and Presence – Confession, community meals, serving the marginalized—not because they fix the system, but because they form us. • Sexual Anxiety & Power in American Evangelicalism – Exploring the Church’s obsession with sexuality through the lens of control and exclusion. • Can the Church Repent? – Wrestling with America’s Christian history rooted in colonization, slavery, and patriarchy, and what repentance looks like today. • Living as a Christian in a Captive Culture – Gombis’s personal posture of engagement: naming complicity, pursuing private transformation, and relinquishing control.

Guest Highlight: Dr. Timothy Gombis – Seminary professor, New Testament scholar, and prophetic voice of humility and hope. Gombis joins the conversation with candor and insight, offering a strong counter-narrative to ambition-driven models of spiritual leadership.

Resources & References: • Matthew 25 – The sheep and goats and Jesus’ judgment based on care for the least of these. • Zondervan “God Bless the USA” Bible – Highlighted as a misguided fusion of nationalism and scripture. • Book on Reparations – Referenced for wrestling with historical sin and the possibility of corporate repentance. • U2’s “Grace” and “Beautiful Day” – Cited for theological reflection on the realism and hope of grace. • Letter Writing to Prisoners – One way Gombis practices quiet, embodied faith. • Rethink Megachurch Podcast Interview (Hillsong Today Show segment) – Source of Tim’s frustration and springboard for the dialogue.

Connect, Respond, and Reflect: This episode doesn’t pull punches, and we invite you to join the conversation. How are you wrestling with the state of the church? What does it mean to be the church in our current age? Email your thoughts to hello@voxpodcast.com and let us know how you’re finding—or struggling to find—Christ’s presence in Christian spaces.

As always, we’re grateful for your time and presence as we pursue the true mission of Jesus together.

Subscribe, leave a review, and consider supporting us on Patreon to keep these conversations going: Patreon.com/voxology

Follow on social: 🟣 Instagram – @voxologypodcast 🔵 Facebook – Voxology Podcast 🐦 Twitter – @mikeerre

Watch on YouTube: Voxology TV

Grab our merch: Voxology on Etsy

More at: VoxologyPodcast.com

Let’s practice love, honesty, and humility as we walk this road together toward New Creation.



As always, we encourage and would love discussion as we pursue. Feel free to email in questions to hello@voxpodcast.com, and to engage the conversation on Facebook and Instagram.

We're on YouTube (if you're into that kinda thing): VOXOLOGY TV.

Our Merch Store! ETSY

Learn more about the Voxology Podcast

Subscribe on iTunes or Spotify

Support the Voxology Podcast on Patreon

The Voxology Spotify channel can be found here: Voxology Radio

Follow us on Instagram: @voxologypodcast and "like" us on Facebook

Follow Mike on Twitter: www.twitter.com/mikeerre

Music in this episode by Timothy John Stafford

Instagram & Twitter: @GoneTimothy