In March 1994, the quiet suburb of Carmel, Indiana was shattered by the brutal murders of siblings Lisa and Nick Allemenos, and their family friend Chris James. What began as a seemingly ordinary evening spiraled into one of Hamilton County’s most savage crimes—three young lives cut short in a chilling act of betrayal and violence. In this episode, we unravel the events leading up to that night, the shocking details of the crime, and the trial that followed. Through court records, survivor accounts, and community reflections, we explore how a senseless decision over drugs and money left a lasting scar on an entire town.
Join Patreon here to binge bonus content! Crime Curious is creating a kick-ass exclusive listener experience | Patreon
Want to just donate to the show? You can do so here:
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/crimecurious
Music By: Michael Drzewiecki
Cover Art By: Charnell
Nicholas George “Nick” Allemenos (1976-1994) - Find a Grave Memorial
Lisa Nicole Allemenos (1980-1994) - Find a Grave Memorial
Christopher Edward “Chris” James (1970-1994) - Find a Grave Memorial
Kofi Modibo Ajabu Seeks Clemency for 240-Year Sentence - Capital B News
IM Crime Files: Deadly Decisions - Indianapolis Monthly
25 years later: 1994 Carmel triple murder tore families apart, brought unlikely friends together
Convicted killer suspected in attack on prison guard | wthr.com