Dan Taberski, host of the new podcast Hysterical, dives into the intriguing world of mass hysteria, unpacking its psychological roots and contemporary relevance. He explores an unsettling 2004 incident in Vancouver that highlighted the phenomenon. The discussion reveals how societal stress can trigger shared symptoms, evidenced by cases like the mysterious Havana Syndrome. Taberski also traces the evolution of hysteria from a misunderstood medical condition to a reflection of cultural anxieties, shedding light on its implications for mental health today.
Mass psychogenic illness is a psychological phenomenon where individuals develop similar symptoms due to observing others, illustrating the mind-body connection.
The historical stigma around hysteria, particularly its misogynistic roots, complicates the recognition and acceptance of mass psychogenic illness as a legitimate condition.
Deep dives
The Incident on the Vancouver Bus
In May 2004, a peculiar event unfolded on a Vancouver city bus, where a passenger's ominous comment to the bus driver seemed to signal the start of a series of mysterious illnesses. After the passenger disembarked, the bus driver and several passengers soon experienced nausea and sickness, prompting emergency services to be called. Despite extensive testing for toxins and other physical causes, investigators found no explanation for the sudden health crisis, leading to the conclusion that 19 individuals had been placed in quarantine. This incident marked a classic case of mass psychogenic illness, where psychological distress is manifested physically among a group.
Understanding Mass Psychogenic Illness
Mass psychogenic illness, distinctively tracing its roots to psychological origin rather than a physical cause, occurs when individuals within a group begin to exhibit similar symptoms after observing others displaying those symptoms. The symptoms can vary widely, including paralysis, unusual laughter, or gastrointestinal issues, all without any identifiable organic cause. The phenomenon resembles a psychological contagion, highlighting the intricate connection between mind and body, as the initial individual suffers yet unknowingly triggers symptoms in others. This connection reiterates the reality of such experiences, distinguishing it from mere faking or exaggeration of discomfort.
The Stigma Surrounding Hysteria
Mass psychogenic illnesses are often dismissed or stigmatized, especially when linked to a historical understanding of hysteria, which is fraught with misogynistic undertones. The term 'hysteria' originates from ancient beliefs surrounding women's health linked to their reproductive organs, dismissing genuine symptoms as mere psychological manifestations. Individuals afflicted by mass psychogenic illness confront a complicated narrative where they are often perceived as exaggerating their symptoms or questioning their sanity. This stigma complicates the acceptance of a diagnosis rooted in psychological dynamics, leading to feelings of invalidation among those affected.
Cultural Context and Mass Psychogenic Illness
Cultural and societal factors play a significant role in the emergence of mass psychogenic illnesses, often surfacing in periods of heightened stress or tension within a community. Events such as the September 11 attacks and concurrent fears of bioterrorism provide insight into how collective anxiety can manifest in physical symptoms among groups of individuals, especially vulnerable populations like schoolchildren. These occurrences reveal an intricate relationship between mental stressors and physical health, illustrating how societal pressures can lead to inexplicable physical reactions like rashes or ticks shared among individuals. As such, acknowledging this connection and recognizing the phenomenon's validity may provide a pathway toward more compassionate and effective responses to those experiencing psychogenic symptoms.
“Hysteria” is an ancient word carrying thousands of years of baggage. Though the terminology has changed, hysteria has not gone away, and in its most baffling instances it can even be contagious. The idea of a mass psychogenic illness can be hard to wrap your head around. A group of people begins experiencing physical symptoms, because of something that started in one of their minds? In today’s episode Dan Taberski, the host of Hysterical, a new podcast about mass hysteria, walks us through the past and present of this phenomenon, why it’s so stigmatized, and why it shouldn’t be.
This episode was written by Evan Chung and Willa Paskin and produced by Evan. We produce Decoder Ring with Katie Shepherd and Max Freedman and with help from Sofie Kodner. Derek John is Executive Producer. Merritt Jacob is Senior Technical Director. Special thanks to Marialexa Kavanaugh and Alexandra Anderson.
If you haven’t please yet, subscribe and rate our feed in Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. And even better, tell your friends.
If you’re a fan of the show, we’d love for you to sign up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get to listen to Decoder Ring and every other Slate podcast without any ads. You also get unlimited access to Slate’s website. Member support is crucial to our work. So please go to slate.com/decoderplus to join Slate Plus today.