Faith Matters

Unpacking Polygamy: Wrestling with 132, with Bethany Brady Spalding, Patrick Mason, and Bill Turnbull

10 snips
Nov 8, 2025
In this engaging conversation, Bill Turnbull, co-founder of Faith Matters and an expert on Mormon history, and Bethany Brady Spalding, a practitioner and writer focused on faith and gender, dig deep into the complexities of polygamy as presented in Doctrine and Covenants Section 132. They explore theological tensions, the contrast between ancient and modern marriage ideals, and the implications of consent. The duo questions the necessity of Section 132 today and shares insights on navigating faith while honoring the higher principles of love and partnership.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Polygamy Contradicts Restorative Theology

  • Bethany argues Section 132 and polygamy contradict the restoration's elevation of women's divine worth.
  • She believes polygamy moved women backward toward being treated as property, not divine partners.
ANECDOTE

A Mentor's Agony Over Eternal Polygamy

  • Bethany shared her mentor's final days when she begged her dying husband not to take another wife in the next life.
  • That fear left the mentor feeling "not enough," illustrating polygamy's emotional legacy.
INSIGHT

Book Of Mormon Condemns Polygamy

  • Jacob (Book of Mormon) explicitly calls David and Solomon's many wives "abominable" and prescribes one wife per man.
  • The text allows a narrow exception "if I will... raise up seed," which should not flip rule and exception.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app