The German Firewall Is Coming Down | Interview: James Kirchick
Mar 3, 2025
auto_awesome
James Kirchick, author of The End of Europe, provides insights into the shifting political landscape in Germany, including the surprising rise of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD). He discusses Vice President J.D. Vance’s provocative speech at the Munich Security Conference and its implications for U.S.-European relations. Kirchick also explores immigration challenges in Europe, critiques Angela Merkel’s policies, and raises concerns over the growing polarization in German politics, all while advocating for more nuanced political discourse.
J.D. Vance's speech at the Munich Security Conference emphasizes internal threats to freedom in Europe, raising significant debate about its implications.
The rise of the far-right Alternative for Germany party, driven by immigration concerns and political fragmentation, indicates troubling shifts in Germany's electoral landscape.
Deep dives
The Importance of Free Speech in Europe
The conversation highlights the critical issue of free speech laws in Europe, particularly in Germany, where restrictions on speech have generated significant debate. J.D. Vance's Munich speech suggests that internal threats to freedom, rather than external aggressors like Russia or China, pose the most significant risk to Europe. This perspective is considered misguided by some, as it overlooks the crucial context of the security conference's purpose, which is primarily focused on rallying allies against common threats. The endorsement of a far-right party, the Alternative for Germany (AFD), during such discussions raises concerns about the implications for democratic collaboration in Europe.
German Elections and Rising Far-Right Influence
Recent German elections marked a pivotal moment, revealing concerning trends in voter support for far-right parties. The AFD secured its highest vote share since World War II, garnering around 21% of the electorate, a stark indicator of shifting political sentiments. This rise comes as traditional major parties, including the Social Democrats, have seen significant losses, suggesting a fragmentation of the political landscape. The political divide between former East and West Germany plays a crucial role, where economically distressed areas show strong support for extreme parties, emphasizing a need for better integration and trust in political institutions.
Angela Merkel's Legacy and the AFD's Emergence
Angela Merkel's immigration policies are identified as a pivotal factor contributing to the rise of the AFD in Germany. The dramatic shift of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) under her leadership to more moderate stances alienated right-leaning voters, leading them to seek representation in the far-right party. As the AFD evolved to more extreme positions, including anti-immigration rhetoric, it capitalized on frustrations about immigration and integration failures. This political evolution illustrates the consequences of failing to address voter concerns about immigration and identity in a changing Europe.
Risks of Dismantling Post-War Alliances
Concerns are raised regarding the potential risks of destabilizing the post-World War II alliances and security structures that have historically bolstered Western democracy and prosperity. Critics argue that undermining NATO and American commitments to its allies could foster a breakdown of the collaborative security framework established over decades. The ramifications of accommodating far-right movements and potential shifts in foreign policy towards adversarial regimes may pose existential threats to the established order. Emphasizing the need for a unified transatlantic response, the belief is strong that destabilizing movements should be resisted to safeguard long-term stability and cooperation.
James Kirchick, author of The End of Europe, joins Jamie Weinstein to discuss Vice President J.D. Vance’s controversial speech at the Munich Security Conference, the recent German elections, and the rise of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party.
The Dispatch Podcast is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including members-only newsletters, bonus podcast episodes, and regular livestreams—click here.