Discover the top 10 reasons why novels get rejected by publishers, from genre mismatch to weak characters and predictable plots. Learn how to identify your target audience, craft captivating story worlds, and develop unique characters with depth. Avoid common pitfalls and enhance your writing with actionable strategies for success.
Researching and targeting agents/publishers aligned with the manuscript's genre reduces rejection chances.
Ensuring error-free, polished submission materials increases the manuscript's appeal to agents and editors.
Deep dives
Category or Genre Fit
One common reason for novel rejection is when the author queries agents or publishers whose focus does not align with the genre or category of the manuscript. This mismatch often occurs due to insufficient research prior to submission. It is essential to target agents or publishers who are passionate about representing works in the specific genre or category the author's manuscript falls under.
Mechanics and Writing Quality
Novels may face rejection if they contain spelling, grammar errors, or lackluster writing in their submission materials. Agents and editors typically scrutinize query letters, synopses, and sample chapters for such issues. Ensuring a polished manuscript before submission and seeking feedback from peers or professional editors can enhance the overall quality of the work.
Target Audience Clarity
Authors must identify and understand their target audience to increase the manuscript's appeal. Generic statements like 'this story will appeal to everyone' may signal a lack of direction. Specific audience targeting enhances marketability and allows agents and editors to visualize the book's potential readership, improving the chances of publication.
In today's episode, I'm going to walk you through 10 common reasons why manuscripts are rejected by publishers. Here's a preview of what's included:
[02:05] After a rejection, you don't have to wait before making your next move. You can get to work right away and figure out what’s wrong with your draft so that you can fix it and resubmit your story. [02:25] Reason #1: The category or genre isn’t the right fit for the agent or the publisher. Usually, this means the author didn't do their research. [03:40] Reason #2: The submission materials are full of bad mechanics (aka poor grammar and spelling) and lackluster writing. [05:15] Reason #3: The author doesn’t know who their target audience is or, even worse, they say their story is for everyone. [07:15] Reason #4: The story world isn’t pulling its weight, or it doesn't feel organic. [08:300] Reason #5: The high-level story summaries are weak or all over the place. [10:15] Reason #6: The characters aren't unique or interesting. They don't pull readers in and get them invested in the story. [11:30] Reason #7: The author lacks a strong voice. [12:25] Reason #8: The plot of the story is predictable or cliche. Usually, this is because your characters are flat or predictable. [14:20] Reason #9: The theme of the story is overbearing and it reads like a lecture. [15:40] Reason #10: The story fails to deliver a powerdul emotional experience to readers. [17:30] Key points and episode recap.
Subscribe & Review in Apple Podcasts
Are you subscribed to my podcast? If not, I want to encourage you to do that today. I don’t want you to miss an episode! Especially because I’m adding a bunch of bonus episodes to the mix and if you’re not subscribed there’s a good chance you’ll miss out on those. So, click here to subscribe to the show in Apple Podcasts!
If you're already a subscriber, and if you enjoy the show, I would be really grateful if you left a review over on Apple Podcasts, too. Those reviews help other writers find my podcast and they’re also super fun for me to go in and read. Just click here to review, select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” and let me know what your favorite part of the show is. Thanks in advance!