Why Happiness Might Be Overrated and What to Aim for Instead

Have you ever felt like you’re supposed to be happy all the time? Like life’s one big Instagram reel of sunny beaches, perfect coffee, and nonstop smiles—and you’re somehow failing if you’re not there yet? I get it. I’ve been there, staring at my phone, wondering why my Tuesday night takeout doesn’t feel like a victory lap. We’re told happiness is the ultimate prize—chase it, grab it, hold it tight. But what if that’s the wrong target? What if chasing happiness is like chasing a mirage—shimmery, tempting, but always just out of reach?

Here’s a thought that might shake things up: happiness isn’t the goal. It’s a fleeting guest, not a permanent roommate. And honestly, that’s okay. Two thinkers from way back—Aristotle from ancient Greece and Lao Tzu from ancient China—had some ideas that cut through the noise. They didn’t chase fleeting joy; they aimed for something deeper: balance and self-awareness. This isn’t about slapping on a fake smile or buying into the “good vibes only” trap. It’s about building a life that feels real, grounded, and worth living, even when the dishes are piling up or life throws a curveball.

So, let’s unpack this. Grab a coffee, a tea, or just a quiet corner, and let’s talk about why happiness might be overrated—and what to aim for instead.

The Happiness Mirage: Why It Keeps Slipping Away

Think about the last time you got something you really wanted—a new gadget, a raise, maybe a killer vacation. Felt amazing, right? For a minute, you’re on top of the world. But then the shine wears off. The phone’s just a phone. The raise comes with more emails. The vacation tan fades, and you’re back to traffic jams and laundry. What gives?

Psychologists call this the hedonic treadmill. It’s the idea that no matter how big the win—or the loss—you tend to slide back to your usual mood pretty fast. Studies show lottery winners are thrilled at first, but within a year, most are about as happy as they were before the jackpot. Same with tough stuff—people adapt, even after major setbacks. It’s like our brains are wired to reset, keeping us hungry for the next “happy” hit.

Why’s this a problem? Because we’ve been sold a story that happiness is out there, waiting in the next purchase, job, or relationship. Ever bought something online, thinking, “This is gonna make me feel awesome”—only to realize it’s just… stuff? Or maybe you’ve scrolled social media, seeing everyone’s highlight reel—weddings, promotions, avocado toast—and felt like you’re missing out. That’s the mirage in action. It looks real, but it’s not built to last.

And here’s the kicker: when you expect to be happy all the time, every off day feels like a personal failure. You start wondering, “What’s wrong with me?” I’ve been there, beating myself up because I wasn’t grinning through a stressful week at work. It’s exhausting, and it can make you feel like you’re doing life wrong.

Thanks for reading Paragon Legacies! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Aristotle’s Big Idea: Flourish, Don’t Just Chase Feelings

Let’s take a trip back to ancient Greece and sit with Aristotle for a minute. This guy wasn’t into chasing warm fuzzies. He talked about something called eudaimonia, which gets translated as “happiness” but is really about flourishing—living your fullest, truest life. It’s not about feeling good every second; it’s about being a person you respect, even when life’s messy.

How do you get there? Aristotle’s got a plan: virtue and the golden mean. Virtue’s about building character—think honesty, courage, kindness. But the golden mean is where it gets practical. It’s about balance—finding the sweet spot between too much and too little. Take courage: charging into every argument is reckless, but dodging every tough talk is cowardly. The middle ground? Knowing when to speak up, like telling a friend they’ve hurt you, and when to let it slide.

Or think about work-life balance. Ever gone all-in on a job, staying late, skipping workouts, only to crash and burn? I have. I used to pull 12-hour days, thinking it’d make me “successful” (and yeah, happy). Spoiler: I was a zombie. Then I started setting boundaries—leaving at 6 p.m., taking walks, saying no to extra projects. I wasn’t bouncing with joy, but I felt solid, like I was building something real. That’s the golden mean—stretching yourself without snapping.

What’s cool about Aristotle’s idea is it’s not about quick fixes. It’s about asking, “Who do I want to be?” Maybe you want to be patient. Next time you’re stuck in traffic, instead of cursing, try breathing and letting it go. Small moves like that add up, making you feel like you’re steering your life, not just riding the waves.

Lao Tzu’s Wisdom: Flow Like Water, Don’t Fight the Current

Now, let’s hop over to ancient China and chill with Lao Tzu, the master of Taoism. His big idea is the Tao—the natural flow of life. Instead of wrestling with every twist and turn, he says to roll with it. His secret? Wu wei, or “effortless action.” It’s not about being lazy; it’s about moving with life’s rhythm, like a river carving its path without forcing it.

For Lao Tzu, chasing happiness is like trying to grab water—it slips through your fingers. The more you fight for it, the more stressed you get. Instead, he’d say, “Let go.” Stop obsessing over the perfect plan or outcome. When you’re in tune with yourself and the moment, peace shows up on its own.

Ever had a day where you stopped stressing and things just clicked? I remember planning an outdoor program down to the last detail—snacks, playlist, weather checks. Then it poured. I was pissed, ready to cancel. But my friend said, “Let’s just go.” We got soaked, slipped in mud, laughed like idiots. It wasn’t the “happy” day I’d pictured, but it felt right. That’s wu wei—letting life happen and finding the magic in it.

Or think about a time you over planned something—a dinner, a project—and it flopped. Now imagine just going with the flow, like cooking whatever’s in the fridge or tackling work one step at a time. It’s not about giving up; it’s about trusting that life doesn’t need to be forced into a box. Lao Tzu’s vibe is freedom—less control, more ease.

The Dark Side of Chasing Happiness

Let’s face it: the chase for happiness can feel like a never-ending hamster wheel that only leaves you more exhausted, frustrated, and convinced that something is wrong with you. Everywhere you turn, you’re told to visualize your dream life, fill gratitude journals first thing in the morning, and recite affirmations until the mirror cracks—but when you inevitably wake up tired, grumpy, or simply “off,” that relentless messaging makes you wonder whether you’re defective. I’ve been there: dragging myself through a day of back-to back calls, feeling the familiar knot of anxiety tightening in my chest, and thinking, “Why can’t I just be happy?” The guilt that follows is a cruel irony feeling broken for what is, at its core, a perfectly normal emotional experience.

Then there’s the seductive promise that a new car, a promotion, or that “right” person will finally unlock lasting joy. I once landed what I thought was my dream job prestigious title, hefty paycheck, the works—and for about ten glorious minutes I floated on genuine excitement. But as the novelty wore off, the email avalanche began, deadlines piled up, and I realized I still felt hollow. It wasn’t the job’s fault no job can fill the gaps you’re trying to fill but pinning your happiness on those external markers is like building your emotional house on stilts: one wobble and you’re left scrambling to stay upright.

And let’s talk about toxic positivity. After a brutal breakup, a chorus of well-meaning voices urged me to “just stay positive” or “you deserve someone better.” Those platitudes felt as useful as a band aid on a broken leg. What I needed was space to sit with the ache, to curse the ceiling at 2 a.m., to learn what the pain was teaching me about my own boundaries and needs. Science tells us that processing grief, anger, and doubt is what builds resilience; stuffing those feelings down only plants the seeds of burnout and disconnection.

Of course, many of us respond by diving headfirst into the next self-help craze meditation apps, vision boards, dopamine detoxes as if unchecked enthusiasm for “happiness hacks” will break the cycle. In reality, you end up policing your every thought did I meditate long enough today? Am I journaling deeply enough? until joy becomes another item on a to do list. It’s ironic that in the frantic pursuit of euphoria, we often lose sight of the present moment where contentment actually lives.

True well-being, I’ve learned, isn’t a destination you arrive at by ticking off an Instagram-approved checklist. It’s the byproduct of a life lived honestly: wrestling with hard truths, investing in relationships without guarantee of perfection, showing up for work and play regardless of the outcome, and granting yourself permission to feel, fully and without apology. When you stop hunting for happiness and instead cultivate curiosity about your own messy, beautiful interior world, contentment begins to emerge—not as a forced performance, but as the quiet accompaniment to a life fully embraced. A gentle reminder, then: it’s okay to be human. Embrace the whole spectrum of your experience, and you’ll find that joy is far more resilient—and far more surprising—than you ever imagined.

The Better Path: Balance and Self-Awareness

So, if happiness is a flaky friend, what’s the move? Aristotle and Lao Tzu point to balance and self-awareness. It’s not about confetti or viral moments—it’s about building a life that feels steady and true. Here’s how to make it work:

* Focus on who you are, not how you feel. Pick a trait you admire—maybe kindness or grit—and lean into it. Next time someone cuts you off in traffic, try a small act of patience, like letting it go instead of honking. It’s not about feeling happy; it’s about liking who you’re becoming.

* Find the middle ground. Extremes burn you out. All work? You’re a husk. All play? You’re broke. Ask yourself, “Where am I overdoing it?” If you’re glued to your desk, carve out an hour for a walk. If you’re binge-watching life away, set one goal for the day. Balance feels like a deep breath.

* Know yourself. Take a minute to ask, “What lights me up? What drags me down?” I did this after a soul-sucking job—realized I love creating but hate micromanaging. So I shifted gears, took on projects I cared about. Not glamorous, but grounding. Try it: jot down one thing you love doing and one thing you dread. Start small.

* Roll with life’s punches. Plans flop? Adapt. Someone cancels? Enjoy the quiet. I learned this when a big presentation tanked—instead of spiraling, I asked for feedback and moved on. Flexibility is power.

* Let happiness sneak in. Stop hunting it. Build a life aligned with your values, and joy will crash the party. I started saying no to stuff that drained me—like endless social obligations—and yes to quiet nights writing. Happiness showed up without me chasing it.

Try This: Small Steps to a Bigger Life

Ready to give it a go? Here’s a starter kit—simple, doable, no overhaul needed:

* Write a gratitude note. Each night, jot down three things that went okay: a good meal, a kind word, making it through a tough day. I started this when life felt heavy—it didn’t fix everything, but it shifted my focus to what’s already good.

* Breathe for five. Inhale for four seconds, exhale for four. Do it when stress hits. I use it when my inbox is a nightmare—calms the storm in my head.

* Flex a virtue. Pick one, like generosity. Today, share a coffee with a coworker. Tomorrow, listen to a friend without interrupting. Small wins feel big over time.

* Drop a “should.” Skip that guilt-trip gym session or extra chore. I ditched a “productive” Sunday once, watched a movie instead. The world kept spinning.

* Dig deeper. Curious? Check out The Happiness Trap by Russ Harris for a modern take, or Lao Tzu’s Tao Te Ching for timeless wisdom. Audiobook it while you cook—insights with your tacos.

The Bottom Line: Build a Life That Lasts

Happiness is a sparkler bright, fun, gone fast. Balance and self-awareness? That’s a campfire warm, steady, built to last. You won’t be grinning ear-to-ear every day, and that’s fine. Life’s not a highlight reel; it’s a mix of grit, growth, and quiet wins.

Next time you’re tempted to chase that “happy” fix—new shoes, a viral post, whatever—pause. Ask yourself, “What’s deeper? What’s true for me?” Start small: say no to one thing, breathe through a tough moment, write down a win. Fulfillment’s a slow burn, not a microwave meal. And trust me, it’s worth it.

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit fulfillmentobi.substack.com