My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark MFM Minisode 455
Sep 29, 2025
This episode dives into riveting listener stories. A hitman plot surfaces from local news, stirring family drama. A fun trivia moment reveals a secret Murderino in the family. Georgia shares a freaky tailgating incident that had her on edge. Twin telepathy takes a twist with a shared nightmare about their mom's visit. Plus, nostalgia strikes with hilarious voicemail pranks from rural times. Get ready for laughter, chills, and relatable childhood tales!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Bar Trivia Revealed A Secret Listener
- A listener hid her My Favorite Murder habit from her parents for eight years and finally outed herself by answering a trivia question about Richard Ramirez.
- She won the game but received judgment from her parents and a small novelty prize.
Aunt Found On News As Hitman Target
- A sender's aunt nearly became a hitman target and only learned about it when her name and address aired on the local evening news.
- The aunt refused interviews, avoided marriage to the man involved, and later married her deceased sister's widower.
Creepy Tailgater On The 101
- Georgia describes a 2007 drive where a car unnervingly matched her speed and flashed lights to make her pull over, then tailgated her for miles.
- She evaded the driver by refusing to stop, exiting and later fleeing at high speed until she reached safety and gas.