The Spy Who

Listen Now: American Scandal | The West Memphis Three

Nov 25, 2025
A small town is rocked when three young boys go missing, leading to a shocking discovery. The investigation faces challenges with limited evidence and community pressure. Instead of justice, it spirals into a web of false accusations against three teenagers. Explore the chaos, media frenzy, and the struggle for truth that ensues, as the story captures national attention and sparks a lengthy fight for justice that resonates for nearly two decades.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Evidence Vacuum Fuels Wild Theories

  • Small-town investigators lacked physical evidence yet pursued any theory to satisfy pressure.
  • That rush to find answers made them vulnerable to wild, unsubstantiated leads.
ANECDOTE

Local Police Push To Keep Control

  • Chief Gary Gitchell tries to reassure the governor he can handle the case locally.
  • He accepts limited state help while insisting West Memphis remain in charge of the investigation.
INSIGHT

Shaky Records Undermine Investigation

  • Investigators had poor documentation and inconsistent interview practices.
  • Those lapses weakened the integrity of the investigation and evidence trail.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app