Scott Beekman, "The Last Gladiator: William Muldoon and the Making of American Sports" (U Texas Press, 2025)

Sep 27, 2025

Scott Beekman, a history professor and sports historian, dives into the life of William Muldoon, a iconic figure in American sports history. They discuss Muldoon’s rise from a poor Irish immigrant to a wrestling champion, trainer, and influential health authority. Beekman reveals how Muldoon's controversial decisions as the chair of the NY Athletic Commission shaped boxing, including enforcing racial segregation. The podcast also touches on Muldoon’s role in reviving John L. Sullivan's career and examines why this once-renowned athlete faded from public memory.

41:21

forum

Ask episode

web_stories

AI Snips

view_agenda

Chapters

menu_book

Books

auto_awesome

Transcript

info_circle

Episode notes

insights

INSIGHT

Three Careers Shaped Sports

William Muldoon had three public careers: wrestler, trainer/physical culturist, and chair of the NY State Athletic Commission.
Each phase let him reshape American sports, fitness culture, and boxing regulation for decades.

insights

INSIGHT

Why Muldoon Became Obscure

Muldoon faded from memory because wrestling lost prestige, his health theories dated badly, and his commission rulemaking angered many.
These combined factors pushed him out of sports historiography despite his prominence.

insights

INSIGHT

Wrestling's Early Prominence

Professional wrestling was among the earliest major U.S. pro sports alongside horse racing and pedestrianism.
19th-century wrestling competed with many now-forgotten popular sports for public attention.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Who Was William Muldoon and Why He Mattered

01:14 • 3min

chevron_right

Why Muldoon Faded from Public Memory

04:22 • 2min

chevron_right

Research Challenges and Sources

06:32 • 2min

chevron_right

The Sporting Landscape of the Late 19th Century

08:08 • 2min

chevron_right

What 19th-Century Professional Wrestling Looked Like

10:10 • 4min

chevron_right

What Made Muldoon a Successful Wrestler

14:10 • 59sec

chevron_right

Did Muldoon Resurrect John L. Sullivan's Career?

15:09 • 5min

chevron_right

Muldoon and the Physical Culture Movement

20:22 • 3min

chevron_right

What Was Neurasthenia and How Muldoon Treated It

23:00 • 3min

chevron_right

How Muldoon Ran Olympia and Treated Clients

26:15 • 2min

chevron_right

Personal Assessment: Is Muldoon Likeable?

28:01 • 1min

chevron_right

Muldoon's Temper, Bridges Burned, and Networking

29:15 • 1min

chevron_right

How Muldoon Became Chair of the NY Athletic Commission

30:40 • 2min

chevron_right

Muldoon's Authoritarian Approach on the Commission

32:36 • 42sec

chevron_right

Muldoon Enforced a Racial Color Line in Boxing

33:18 • 2min

chevron_right

Why New York Mattered in 1920s Boxing

34:50 • 45sec

chevron_right

Public Perception and Legacy at Muldoon's Death

Why Muldoon Disappeared from History

38:22 • 1min

chevron_right

Author's Favorite Sports Books

Moses Malone: The Life of a Basketball Prophet

null

Paul Knepper

The Knicks of the Nineties: Ewing, Oakley, Starks and the Brawlers That Almost Won

Ewing, Oakley, Starks and the Brawlers That Almost Won

Paul Knepper

Paul Knepper's "The Knicks of the Nineties" is a captivating account of the New York Knicks team during the 1990s. The book focuses on the key players Patrick Ewing, Charles Oakley, and John Starks, highlighting their contributions to the team's success. It delves into the team's dynamic and their almost-victorious playoff runs. Knepper's work captures the essence of the era, showcasing the team's spirit and their impact on basketball fans. The book offers a nostalgic journey for Knicks fans and a compelling read for basketball enthusiasts.

The Last Gladiator

William Muldoon, and the Making of American Sports

Scott Beekman

The book offers a deep and insightful exploration into Muldoon's life and influence, highlighting his often-controversial role in the evolution of American sports, professional wrestling, and physical and popular culture. It uncovers Muldoon's beginnings as a child of Irish immigrants and his rise to fame in the post-Civil War era. The book also explores his transition into acting, modeling, fitness and political power. The book sheds light on Muldoon's significant impact on the development of American sports.

#9873

• Mentioned in 4 episodes

The breaks of the game

David Halberstam

The Breaks of the Game offers an unparalleled glimpse into the gritty, high-stakes world of professional basketball during the late 1970s. Through the lens of the Portland Trail Blazers' 1979-1980 season, Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist David Halberstam explores the intense pressures faced by players, coaches, and team owners as they navigate the emerging complexities of the NBA. The book includes fascinating profiles of legendary superstars Bill Walton and Kermit Washington and delves into broader societal issues such as race, class, and the evolution of basketball from a sport to a commercial spectacle. It provides a deep understanding of the psychological, emotional, and physical challenges that define the lives of professional athletes, backed by rigorous research and insightful analysis.

The Manly Art

Elliot Gorn

The book examines the history of bare-knuckle prize fighting in America. It explores the cultural and social context of the sport, focusing on its appeal to working-class men. It uncovers the key figures and events that shaped the era. It explores the connection to masculinity and the role of violence. It illustrates how prize fighting became a spectacle that reflected the values of a changing society.

City Games

Stephen Reese

The book deals with social and cultural aspects of urban life during the late 19th century, examining how leisure activities, including sports and games, reflected and shaped city dwellers' identities. It explores how these activities helped to build a sense of community and belonging. It reveals how class, gender, and ethnicity influenced participation in leisure activities. The book offers insights into the development of American cities and the evolving nature of social life. It provides a comprehensive portrait of leisure and culture in the urban landscape of the late 1800s.

Can't anybody here play this game?

Jimmy Breslin

The book offers a contemporary account of the 1962 New York Mets. It chronicles the team's inaugural season, marked by struggles and mishaps. It highlights the challenges of building a team from scratch and their efforts to compete. The book reveals behind-the-scenes stories, shedding light on the players, management, and the construction of Shea Stadium. It captures the essence of the era and the spirit of a team that became known for its underdog status.

Rigside, a History of Professional Wrestling

Scott Beekman

The book delves into the captivating history of professional wrestling. It traces wrestling's evolution from its folk roots to its transformation into a captivating form of entertainment. The book explores the key figures and events that shaped the sport. The book also examines the cultural significance of professional wrestling and its influence on society. The book also highlights how wrestling became a form of popular entertainment.

Heaven is a playground

Rick Telander

The book delves into the world of street basketball in Brooklyn, New York. It follows the lives of young players and their dreams of making it to the NBA. It captures the raw energy and passion of the streetball scene. It explores the social and economic challenges faced by the players, highlighting their determination and resilience. The book showcases the power of basketball to transform lives and offers a glimpse into a vibrant and often overlooked subculture.

William Muldoon was an infamous athlete whose prowess, savvy, and chicanery across his six-decade career led him to wealth, cultural importance, and political power. Muldoon, the child of poor Irish immigrants, began wrestling in the 1870s and quickly became one of the most famous athletes of the post–Civil War era. He started acting and modeling as his popularity grew, making him one of the first sports stars to achieve crossover success. After a triumphant stint rehabilitating fallen boxing heavyweight champion John L. Sullivan in 1889, he retired from the ring and began a new career as a fitness impresario, founding an elite gymnasium and remaking himself as a health authority in the press. He became trainer to the rich, famous, and politically powerful, which led to his appointment as chair of the New York State Athletic Commission in the 1920s. From this position, Muldoon exerted his influence over the rules of boxing and wrestling and weaponized his power to maintain segregation in sport.

The Last Gladiator: William Muldoon and the Making of American Sports (U Texas Press, 2025) is a deep, insightful dive into Muldoon’s life and impact, demonstrating the significance of this often-controversial figure in the development of American sports, professional wrestling, and physical and popular culture.

Paul Knepper covered the New York Knicks for Bleacher Report. His first book was The Knicks of the Nineties: Ewing, Oakley, Starks and the Brawlers That Almost Won It All. His next book, Moses Malone: The Life of a Basketball Prophet, will be out on November 1. You can reach Paul at paulknepper@gmail.com and follow him on Twitter @paulieknep.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Support our show by becoming a premium member! https://newbooksnetwork.supportingcast.fm/new-books-network

Home Top podcasts Popular guests Top books