
Mike Birbiglia's Working It Out Jon Rudnitsky Returns to Answer More of Your Questions About Comedy
Oct 12, 2026
Jon Rudnitsky, the comedian, actor, and former Saturday Night Live performer, returns for listener questions and lively comedy riffing. He and Mike revisit their Nantucket gigs, debate when a joke has run its course, and spotlight underrated comedy towns. They also tackle audience awareness, Meghan Trainor’s singing challenge, rat-trap physical comedy, aging, and Jon’s upcoming special, Special Boy.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Nantucket Reframed Jon’s Career
- Jon Rudnitsky felt discouraged touring small towns after SNL, but opening for Mike Birbiglia in Nantucket restored his sense of perspective.
- After two strong shows, swimming with Mike and Lucy, he realized the present moment was better than his remembered peak at 25.
Turning Nantucket Into Material
- Jon turned Nantucket’s whaling museum, antique ducks, and expensive lodging into sharply local material.
- His proposed guest-house request became a joke about treating audience members like VIP hosts after a show.
Let Stories Breathe Before The Punchline
- Jon often rushes to the joke because he fears losing the audience, while Mike encourages him to stay inside the story.
- Jon’s family material gains depth by contrasting his father’s meeting anxiety with his mother’s cheerful chaos.
