Alistair Dawber, Washington correspondent, The Times and The Sunday Times, joins the podcast to discuss Alabama's decision to execute death row inmate Kenneth Smith via nitrogen suffocation. Topics include the use of untested methods, the traumatic experience of families on death row, concerns for justice, challenging the method of execution, and reflections on Kenny Smith's potential execution.
Alabama plans to execute death row inmate Kenneth Smith using an untested method - nitrogen suffocation, raising concerns about its humaneness and safety.
The case highlights the flaws and controversy surrounding the death penalty in the United States and the emotional toll it takes on the family of the condemned.
Deep dives
Kenneth Smith's botched execution and survival
Kenneth Eugene Smith, a 58-year-old man who has spent over 30 years on death row in the Holman Correctional Center in southern Alabama, survived a botched execution in November 2022. He was scheduled for execution on January 25th, with a new method involving the use of pure nitrogen to induce suffocation. Smith's lawyers have appealed, arguing that this method is cruel and unusual. While the state of Alabama claims it is a humane way to execute prisoners, it is worth noting that even veterinarians refuse to use nitrogen gas to euthanize animals. Smith's case has brought attention to the flaws and controversy surrounding the death penalty in the United States.
Kenneth Smith's family and their perspective
Kenny Smith's family, including his wife Dala, still live in Alabama and have been living under the shadow of his impending execution for over 30 years. Dala, who married Kenny seven years ago, has become an advocate for his case. The family has had limited contact with Kenny due to the distance between their homes and the prison. They have expressed concerns about the potential violent nature of the nitrogen hypoxia execution method and the emotional toll it takes on them. The looming execution has caused anxiety and distress for the family, who have been closely following the legal proceedings.
The controversial use of nitrogen hypoxia as a method of execution
The state of Alabama's decision to use nitrogen gas as a new method of execution has raised concerns about its safety and humaneness. While nitrogen makes up a significant portion of the air we breathe, breathing pure nitrogen can cause suffocation without any warning signs or symptoms. Critics argue that the method is untested and potentially dangerous, not only for the condemned but also for the personnel administering it. Furthermore, the fact that even veterinarians refuse to use nitrogen to euthanize animals raises questions about its suitability as a method of execution. The legal battle surrounding Kenneth Smith's case sheds light on the ongoing debate around the ethics and efficacy of capital punishment in the United States.
After trying - and failing - to kill him via lethal injection, Alabama is planning to execute death row inmate Kenneth Smith next week using an untested method - nitrogen suffocation. But why are they resorting to this? And could he get a last minute reprieve?
Today's episode contains descriptions of death and execution, right from the start - so do consider if you want to listen.
This podcast was brought to you thanks to the support of readers of The Times and The Sunday Times. Subscribe today: thetimes.co.uk/storiesofourtimes.
Guest: Alistair Dawber, Washington correspondent, The Times and The Sunday Times.