Morbid Episode 664: David Carpenter: The Trailside Killer (Part 2)
Apr 17, 2025
From a playful start on personal aesthetics to serious reflections on the justice system, the hosts tackle the chilling history of David Carpenter, the Trailside Killer. They delve into the haunting unsolved murders connected to him and the failures of California's sex offender registry. Tension rises with disturbing hiking encounters, revealing the chaos of survival in the wilderness. Eyewitness accounts and bizarre behaviors during police interrogations outline the investigation, all while weaving in themes of hiking culture and community support.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Justice System Failures
- David Carpenter's parole and reintegration to society demonstrated the failure of the justice system to contain him.
- Multiple chances were given despite his violent history, highlighting systemic oversight and risk.
False Holdup Story
- After Barbara Schwartz's murder, Carpenter wounded himself and claimed a fake holdup at a 7-Eleven.
- Police accepted his story despite no robbery reports, missing the opportunity to detain him.
Survivor Pursues Attacker
- Steve Hertel was shot while protecting his girlfriend Ellen during an attack by Carpenter on Mount Tam.
- Despite severe wounds, Steve pursued the attacker to warn others, showing incredible courage.