Steve Herman, a longtime Voice of America correspondent and author, shares insights about the impact of recent government actions on the iconic broadcaster. Sarah Ellison, media reporter at The Washington Post, discusses Carrie Lake's controversial appointment and its implications for journalistic integrity. They explore the historical significance of VOA, its mission to deliver credible news, and the repercussions of its shutdown on global awareness. The conversation highlights the ongoing tensions between political influence and independent journalism.
The elimination of Voice of America by the Trump administration marks a significant blow to unbiased global news and democracy promotion.
Carrie Lake's appointment as VOA head illustrates internal conflicts over the agency's direction amidst political pressures and operational challenges.
Deep dives
The Purpose and Impact of Voice of America
Voice of America (VOA) was established during World War II to counter Axis propaganda with American narratives, promoting democracy and offering news coverage globally. Initially broadcasting in German and Japanese, it adapted its language offerings over time, depending on geopolitical needs, and has played a crucial role in providing information to people in various regions. The unique approach of VOA, to report facts without bias, helped establish its credibility, distinguishing it from other state-funded broadcasters that function primarily as propaganda tools. Historical accounts suggest that VOA and similar services contributed to significant political changes, including the fall of the Berlin Wall by providing hope and alternative perspectives to those living under authoritarian regimes.
Recent Changes and Executive Order Implications
In a surprising turn of events, an executive order signed by the President led to the sudden cessation of VOA broadcasts after more than 80 years, a move raising concerns among international audiences. The decision resulted in numerous VOA staff members being placed on administrative leave, with some questioning the motivations behind the shutdown tied to perceived biases in reporting. This abrupt halt in programming has left many foreign listeners, particularly in autocratic countries, anxious and uncertain about the reasons behind the silence of what has historically been a critical source of information. The implications of such a move are seen as significant by observers who argue that it undermines the U.S. commitment to soft power and global communication.
Leadership Challenges and Future of VOA
Carrie Lake's appointment as head of Voice of America came amidst a backdrop of political tension and scrutiny regarding the agency's role. Initially expressing intentions for reform, Lake faced challenges from within the administration that aimed to undermine VOA's legacy and operations, including the cancellation of significant news contracts. Reports indicated that Lake found herself at odds with political figures who preferred a more drastic overhaul of the organization rather than constructive reforms, leading to internal conflicts. Ultimately, while she sought to salvage VOA amidst these changes, many observers doubt her ability to influence its direction as the agency's functionality and output continue to dwindle under the current administration.
President Donald Trump has ordered the federally funded broadcaster to be “eliminated.” Longtime VOA correspondent Steve Herman explains why it will be missed.
This episode was produced by Gabrielle Berbey and Travis Larchuk with help from Miles Bryan, edited by Miranda Kennedy, fact-checked by Laura Bullard and Amanda Lewellyn, engineered by Patrick Boyd and Andrea Kristinsdottir, and hosted by Sean Rameswaram.
