David Gushee, a Distinguished University Professor of Christian Ethics and Director at Mercer University, discusses his new book, 'After Evangelicalism.' He delves into the disillusionment many feel toward evangelicalism, particularly regarding its alignments with systemic racism and exclusion of LGBTQ+ individuals. The conversation explores the moral collapse within evangelical communities, and Gushee proposes a reimagined, inclusive approach to faith. He emphasizes the importance of rediscovering Jesus beyond traditional boundaries while advocating for social justice and personal evolution in belief.
The podcast highlights the emergence of a post-evangelical identity as individuals seek authentic faith expressions beyond traditional evangelical frameworks.
David Gushee critically examines the historical entrenchment of white supremacy within evangelicalism, urging a reckoning and broader understanding of faith that includes social justice.
The conversation emphasizes reimagining theology and salvation from individualistic to community-centered approaches, fostering collective responsibility and engagement with social issues.
Deep dives
The Emergence of a Post-Evangelical Identity
The emergence of a post-evangelical identity is explored as individuals grapple with disillusionment and alienation from traditional evangelicalism. Many find themselves navigating a complicated relationship with their prior beliefs, particularly in light of the political climate and pressures surrounding evangelical movements. This shift has led to a quest for a new faith expression that moves beyond a strict association with evangelical labels, emphasizing the need for personal narrative and authenticity in faith journeys. The conversations surrounding this identity highlight a longing for deeper spiritual engagement that resonates with contemporary issues while shedding outdated ideologies.
Critique of White Supremacy in Evangelicalism
The deep-rooted issues of white supremacy within evangelicalism are critically examined, recognizing how historical and systemic structures have shaped the movement's trajectory. The dominance of white evangelicalism often sidelines diverse theological perspectives and reinforces a narrow interpretation of faith that overlooks marginalized voices. This historical analysis calls for a reckoning with the past and an acknowledgment of the factors contributing to the moral and ethical failures that many are now rejecting in evangelical communities. By interrogating these power dynamics, the conversation encourages a broader understanding of faith that encompasses social justice and human dignity.
Reimagining Theology and Scripture
The podcast delves into reimagining theology and scripture, encouraging a return to biblical narratives and a reevaluation of cherished doctrines through a more inclusive lens. This rethinking involves revisiting historical sources and acknowledging their significance beyond traditional evangelical interpretations, paving the way for a more expansive understanding of God and the community of faith. It offers a constructive exploration of who Jesus is and what it means to live out a faith that is engaging, transformative, and rooted in love rather than exclusion. This process is framed as essential for those rediscovering their spiritual path beyond evangelical confines.
Salvation as Community-Centered
The concept of salvation is transformed from an individualistic focus to a community-centered understanding that emphasizes the shared responsibility for creation and one another. This broader view of salvation champions the need for collective engagement with social issues and recognizes the interconnectedness of all beings. The conversation challenges traditional evangelical narratives that prioritize personal salvation and encourages a holistic approach that honors the dignity of community relationships. This shift invites a deeper exploration of how faith can manifest in acts of service, justice, and care for the environment.
Reencountering Jesus Beyond Tradition
The journey of reencountering Jesus after leaving evangelicalism is portrayed as both challenging and liberating, as individuals seek a relationship that transcends previous experiences within toxic communities. This exploration calls upon those disillusioned by evangelical practices to rediscover the essence of Jesus' teachings, which center on love, acceptance, and authentic connection. By stepping away from the confines of their former traditions, individuals can find new meaning and hope in their faith journeys. This reencounter emphasizes the importance of nurturing a direct relationship with the divine that is free from the burdens of past affiliations.
David Gushee returns to the podcast for a book launch party!
His brand new book After Evangelicalismis out and we had a live stream book launch. It was a bunch of fun to reconnect with David and celebrate my new favorite book of his.
Dr. David P. Gushee is Distinguished University Professor of Christian Ethics and Director of the Center for Theology and Public Life at Mercer University. Dr. Gushee is the elected Past-President of both the American Academy of Religion and Society of Christian Ethics.
Book Details... A building crescendo of developments, culminating in evangelical support for the Trump presidency, has led many evangelicals to question the faith they inherited. If being Christian means rejecting LGBTQ persons and supporting systemic racism, perhaps their Christian journey is over.
David Gushee offers a new way forward for disillusioned post-evangelicals by first analyzing what went wrong with U.S. white evangelicalism in areas such as evangelical identity, biblical interpretation, church life, sexuality, politics, and race. Gushee then proposes new ways of Christian believing, belonging, and behaving, helping post-evangelicals from where they are to a living relationship with Christ and an intellectually cogent and morally robust post-evangelical faith. After Evangelicalism shows that it is possible to follow Jesus out of evangelical Christianity, and more than that, it's necessary.